Bathroom Cabinet DIY Fail

Woodshop Diaries
by Woodshop Diaries
I had an the other day. And since you all chose to follow my blog, I assume you’re in it for better or for worse….the good the bad and the ugly, right? So I can tell you about all the awesome things that turned out even better than I expected. And I can also tell you about all the things that turned out so bad I just want to set them on fire.
So, let me share with you the story of my bathroom cabinet idea that was a total flop.
As many of you know, we remodeled our master bathroom over the last month or so. Truth is, functionally, it’s finished (HALLELUJAH). But, I haven’t posted a “final reveal” yet because a few details are still out there to be decided on. One of those details is what should go above the toilet. (Another is a shower curtain, another is a bath rug, anther is hand towels, and a soap dispenser….you know…ALL THOSE LITTLE DETAILS.)
Let’s just focus on the above the toilet issue. And, while EVERYONE has either a cabinet or floating shelves above their toilet, I wanted something “different.” When I did my Hometalk Live House Tour a while back, I asked your opinion on what I should put here and the winning option was corner shelves. It was a great idea! But when I made them, it just didn't feel right and the shelves stuck out too far from the wall, and it felt crowded when you walked in the door. It's hard to explain...but it just wasn't going to work. So I searched for a plan B.
So I found an idea that I thought might work so I plugged in the shop radio and got to work. I sang and I danced and sawed my little heart out. This was going to be awesome and fun and the coolest part of the whole bathroom!
Then I hung it up and I hated it.
What happened? I had this all planned out. This was going to look awesome. I was going to be able to check it off the list. I had a mental deadline. I needed to show everyone the finished room. If this cabinet didn’t work out, I didn’t have a back up plan!


But, I couldn’t figure out what was wrong. It looked strange above the toilet. It should have been shorter. Danny thought it should hang a little higher. I needed to fill in the pocket holes so you didn’t see them. Maybe the door should have been slightly wider. But, I didn’t trash it just yet. I still had hope!


Maybe a little paint and stain would fix it.
Nope, still hated it. AHH! I hate painting and I just spent my evening painting and staining this thing. What a waste! It looked out of place. It looked kind of janky. It looked like a rushed, not very well planned out DIY job. (Which it kind of was…) And I really wish I hadn’t painted it white.


I texted it to several friends and asked their opinion. They assured me it wasn’t really that bad, but maybe I could tweak this or tweak that to make it better. But, the more I looked at it, the more I hated it.


Now, truth be told, I hate just about everything I ever make before I love it. I have learned, it truly is just part of the process. But this hate was different. Sometimes I hate something but I know it will grow on me and then it’ll be my favorite thing ever. And sometimes I know the feeling won’t change.
So I took down the awful cabinet and patched the drywall and touched up the paint. And I took a step back and realized I’ve just got to wait. I’ve got to wait to “reveal” this bathroom because it’s STILL not done. I’ve got to wait to figure out the perfect thing to put here that gives me all the warm fuzzies.


Not all my projects turn out to be what I had planned. And although, I don’t have plans for a super cool project for you to try in this post, I hope it is encouraging for you to know that we all fail sometimes. My “design” ideas are usually not the best. I am just winging it most of the time. So don’t be scared to try something new. Sometimes it’s a smashing success, and sometimes it’s a failure. But it’s always better than not trying.


Said all that to say get out there and make something–even if it’s a failure, you can still have a bonfire 😉 It is fall, after all! So if you guys need me, I’ll be drinking pumpkin spice lattes and waiting for inspiration to strike. Maybe this time it’ll work out better. Until next time, happy DIYing 🙂


PS I'm working on another project that might work out better and hope to show you all soon. If you want to see the bathroom progress so far, be sure to check out my blog for lots of updates and a reveal VERY soon!
Woodshop Diaries
Want more details about this and other DIY projects? Check out my blog post!
Go
Frequently asked questions
Have a question about this project?
Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 4 comments
  • Amy P. Amy P. on Oct 19, 2016
    I can't even begin to tell you how me this post is! I start things with a vision, but sometimes not a plan, and I wing it until I figure it out. Right now it concerns two very small nightstands, I've painted and sanded and painted and sanded, only to tell you I'm not thrilled with anything I've picked. It finally came together when I realized the colors I picked were my taste, not going with the style of the tables. I switched gears, picked a more provincial color, and BAM! It all came together. But sometimes what we want isn't what we think we want, and we have to just wait it out. Best of luck, and thanks for keeping it real.
  • Marguerite Crain Marguerite Crain on Oct 22, 2016
    Maybe a pull-down door would do it?
Next