Should I paint my interior doors black?

Sue Curwin
by Sue Curwin
We are renovating our 50 year old house that we purchased, and we are replacing all the hollow mahogany doors with updated white doors. As well, we are replacing all the trim. We will most likely be staying in our house for the next 5 years. After that, not sure. My question is would it devalue our house if I painted all the interior doors black (white trim)? Thanks
Sue@housepretty
New Brunswick, Canada
  8 answers
  • If the wooden doors are paint quality and not stain quality, no you will not hurt the value. If you were to paint a stain grade door or trim and cover the beauty of that quality, again you would not hurt value but you would be nuts to do it. A 50 year old home that has hollow core luan doors they really do not offer any value at all. So replacing them perhaps with a raised panel colonial style door with trims might even increase the value. Had the house been a 100 year old home, then there is more value in the doors and restoring them would be a better option. And because your planning to stay there is no reason why you should not paint them the color of your choice. But remember, black doors are not the norm, and any color choices that you make that personalize your home will make it more difficult later on to sell it as most do not paint interior doors dark colors. So be prepared to repaint them again prior to selling if you want to sell quicker.
  • Sue Curwin Sue Curwin on Mar 19, 2014
    These doors are the cheap kind of mahogany, and that is why we are replacing them. As far as the painting of them, ugh! I would SO love to paint them a color, but if we end up selling our house in 5 years, I'm not much looking forward to having to repaint them. Thanks for the answer. I appreciate it!
  • Z Z on Mar 19, 2014
    I'm with Bob (WE) on this. Black painted interior doors are a trend that not too many are following, which would seem that not that many care for them, so I'd not paint them black. What style is your home Sue?
  • Z Z on Mar 19, 2014
    By the way Sue, have you gotten started on the fireplace surround yet? Are you still planning on using the idea from my virtual? I think it was this one you liked the most.
  • Sue Curwin Sue Curwin on Mar 20, 2014
    So sad, Becky, just so sad lol! Because they look so darn sharp, in a very sophisticated kind of way. Then again, I have too many other things I want done to this house to want to have to paint them out again in a couple of years. My house is a 4 level back split (?). The back door is on the side of the house. Going down from the back door, you have two other levels.
    • See 2 previous
    • Z Z on Mar 20, 2014
      @Sue, I didn't realize you had already purchased the doors. If you're like us, we pay cash for everything for our home so that, and the fact you said you'd be there only five years, was what made me think of the trim on the current doors. Don't worry about the "book". I'm an avid reader. If even read the backs of cans, boxes. If it has words, I read it. I used to be a reading teacher's assistant. I miss my students. My students from my first year of teacher range in age from 23 to 29! Gosh I'd love to meet them again.
  • Sue Curwin Sue Curwin on Mar 20, 2014
    Ah, you remember me! As much as I loved (!!!) that look, in the end, I didn't want to give my husband more work. He's so, SO tired of home renovations! So, after thinking, and thinking, and some more thinking, I think (lol!) I'm going to go with painting the fireplace out. An acquaintance from church had us drop by her house, since she painted hers out, and my husband actually loved it! We are also getting a new, "wireless" TV, to eliminate the "clutter", and put that TV downstairs in our family room, since the one we have down there is on it's last legs, and could have come out of the ark, lol! The paintings have also been removed and have gone in other rooms. Bit, by bit, it's looking a lot less cluttered. I was going to post pictures, but I have been having computer problems, AND I am working on a new blog, so I wanted to save my "good stuff" for the fresh new one. By the way, thanks so much for remembering me! And sorry for the "novel"!
    • See 2 previous
    • Z Z on Mar 20, 2014
      @Sue, yes, we have a sunroom with hardwood floors and bead board and somewhat of a "mini" coffered ceiling in progress. It's off the kitchen so we have our dining table in there. When in the planning stages I drew up some changes for the architect, closing off one door and opening up another doorway to make what would have been the dining room into a library. As mentioned above, I love to read. So does my hubby and our son who, with his six year old son, lives with us. A library is a must with all the books we have. None of us have yet folded to a reader tablet. LOL
  • Pat Pat on Mar 20, 2014
    Classic white 6 panel doors are never out of style.
  • Sue Curwin Sue Curwin on Mar 24, 2014
    Thanks for the input!