Asked on Jul 31, 2014

Shade for lamp? what kind?

Bernice H
by Bernice H
I just got these lamps at gwill.. but the shade I have on hand bothers me. I know it is not right, but not sure what kind is needed. any suggestions?
  14 answers
  • Patricia Rodowsky Patricia Rodowsky on Jul 31, 2014
    Maybe a bell shaped fabric shade?
  • Linda Meyer-Kelly Linda Meyer-Kelly on Jul 31, 2014
    What about an acordian like shape (ribbed), sand color, a little larger than the one shown?
  • Theresa Vallier-Thomas Theresa Vallier-Thomas on Aug 01, 2014
    I'd put a drum shade on it, assuming you want a more updated look to the lamps.
  • Jody51 Jody51 on Aug 01, 2014
    I'd try a shade a little larger & like Theresa said a drum shape would be good. But I think some soft color &/or fabric shade would help a lot. Maybe a soft bronze/chiffon or more dramatic play up the red instead. Good luck, have fun!
  • Kay Ellen Tomlinson Kay Ellen Tomlinson on Aug 01, 2014
    Because of the decoration on the base, I feel a pagoda shade would work really well.
  • Jeanette S Jeanette S on Aug 01, 2014
    Have you thought about a red shade? Maybe in one of those different shapes other than round that we are seeing these days (they are very interesting...some are wider than tall!! And I think the shade needs t be a tad larger...taller and wider. Another thought just hit me...why not get the right size shade and cover it in gold paper! BTW, these lamps are pretty enough to put some money into the right shade!
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Aug 02, 2014
    Thank you all..I took one of the lamps to a lighting store today and got professional help!! We tried several shades . I learned a lot. I finally realized I just was not used to the LAMP shape itself. I have had big Jar type for years that I keep spray painting. I am not used to a slim tall skinny look. We decided an off white in color and maybe a pagoda style would look good. They had none in the size needed , and I was glad because they were pricey. @Jeanette S 95$ yikes! and I needed 2? so I will keep looking. I learned it was the NECK that bothered me. It is tall and I kept thinking it should be covered, reminded me of a giraffe. I had been thinking a shade that comes down covering most of the neck, but she said no. the shade should just come to just about the bottom of metal part under the harp, and be sure you have the right size harp. We tried 8 and 9 inches and 8 was the best. I am also thinking a special finial would finish it off. I am just not used to ANYTHING skinny around here! ha
  • Michele Eures Michele Eures on Aug 02, 2014
    I think it might be because it's out of proportion to the table it's sitting on. It's too tall for it. If it were sitting on a large dresser or buffet it would look better. Also, I agree with Jeanette S about the red lamp shade. You can always paint a shade you find that you like but isn't the right color.
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Aug 02, 2014
    Oh my goodness, I think you are right!!!!!!!!!!! the lady did mention that, oh dear now what do I do? My chairs are right there, these are reading/task lamps. and the end tables are necessary, and cant be bigger or taller than they are. Yes at 4 A.m I can see what you are saying. So the fat shorter lamps have to come back in? I love these, but now not so much!! aacckk! Thank you @Michele Eures And I have no where to put them. And I have a thing for lamps~!
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Aug 02, 2014
    @Michele Eures @Jeanette S Here is a pic of what Michele mentioned. This is the other chair..Yes I can see it now. sighhhhh
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Aug 03, 2014
    @Arlene White Stricker hahahahahaaaaaa What a hoot! NO no no they are not plastic curtains, tooo funny! I haven't seen plastic curtains since I had them in the 60-70's! hahaha NO these are Pier One, , tan sheer, burnouts..had them for years, they don't make them any more either. thanks for noticing.
    • Arlene White Stricker Arlene White Stricker on Aug 14, 2014
      Goodness. I'm sorry for implying they were plastic. Too hard to tell on the screen. Up close burnout is really pretty.
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Aug 14, 2014
    Nooo problem...I can see They do look like plastic ...wow , that has been along time. Have you seen any ? Do they still make them? We were military..and moved every 2 years, so yes I had them , but that was before 1980.
  • LindaK LindaK on Feb 02, 2016
    I think that a drum shade shape would look nice as long as it was in proportion.
  • NancyMaria NancyMaria on Mar 31, 2016
    Don't think of the skinny giraffe neck, step back and look at the shape like a flower vase, and the shade will be the flowers. Both can bring beauty into the room. With that shape vase you probably would not cut flower short but extend the whole look with long stems. A vase was the first thing that came to my mind when I saw the lovely bases.
    • Bernice H Bernice H on Mar 31, 2016
      Thank You NancyMaria. Yup..we have made do with present shade. Hubs has lamp by his side of the bed,and likes the shade as is so he can read! Go figure! So it doesn't bother me anymore!