« View Post
Photos

Oops! Leave without saving?

If you leave this page, the information you have entered will not be saved!
Are you sure you want to leave this page?

Leave this page Stay on this page

Hometalk.com

  • Sign Up
  • or
  • Log In
  • Professionals
  • Community
    • All Members
    • Professionals
    • Bloggers
  • About
    • About Hometalk
    • Blog
    • FAQ
    • Guidelines
    • Resources
    • Support
    • Press
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
  • Following
  • All Topics
    • Cleaning & Organization
    • Crafts
    • Design & Décor
    • DIY Projects
    • Gardening
    • Home Maintenance & Repairs
    • Outdoor Living
    • Painting
    • Remodeling
    • Repurposing & Upcycling
    See More Topics »
  • Questions
    • All Questions
    • Open Questions
    • Unanswered Questions
  • Clips
Post & Ask
Join Now Log In

Hometalk is where people share and help with everything home & garden

0
Connie Nikiforoff Designs
Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND on Aug 02, 2012
Like Clip

Home carpet cleaners - Which would you choose?

I'm going to buy a home carpet cleaner.What's your experience with any? Which would you choose and why? I'm hoping not to spend too much on one...but sometimes you do actually get what you pay for ;-)

If you want to chime in on this one, be swift! I'm planning to purchase today or tomorrow :-)

  • Like Clip
Post Comment | Like | Clip | Share
2440 Views
36 Comments Displaying 25 of 36 comments | See Previous
  • Sharon F Laveen, AZ
    I bought a remanufactured Bissel Pro heat 2X from Big Lots for less than $100.00 and it is fabulous! I too forgot to switch the lever over to clean and it still cleaned very well with just water!
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Well I'm seeing Bissel ProHeat coming up with good reviews here! That's good to know. It also got good reviews online. As for Hoover, the model our local store has on sale, didn't fare so well in the reviews ;-( And when I called the store to get the model #, the guy says "What do you need that for?" Ummm.....if they're afraid of a potential customer doing a little background check on their merchandise before buying, I'm not sure I want to shop there. Although years and years ago I did ...»
    get a Riccar vacuum there...and it works fantastic on pet hair and sand.

    I don't anticipate shampooing very frequently (we have dogs but they get their feet wiped off before they come inside if they've gotten wet/dirty) and we're a "shoes off" family so maybe I don't need a "monster" shampooer(?) Still I don't want a flimsy made one either.

    I still will appreciate any other comments from readers ;-) Thanks all you guys for chiming in. (I've yet to get my carpets vacuumed today...I am SO behind! Haha!)

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Nancy young Rochester, MI
    I am having a problem with my brand ew Bissell Proheat carpet machine. I used it once, and the second time the water woudn't spray out of the machine. However, if I take the unit off the stand it works as a portable. I called the manufacturer and they were not of any help. Any one know what the poblem might be?
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Nancy---Have you checked to see if there's some debris in the water line that directly attaches to where it comes out into the "main" machine? Just a thought...I'm the one here who's buying for the first time. :-)
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Peggy C Chesapeake, VA
    I have thought of buying a carpet cleaner also, however, my fear is that it will leave too much wet in the carpet as I have found even with professional cleaners. My daughter used a rented Rug Doctor on our rental house and it left a nasty mess below the carpet. Does the Bissell really get most of the water up?
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Yes, like Peggy C wonders, do any of these carpet shampooers really get up all the water? I think some do a better job than others. On the other hand, we have to remember we are using water ;-)

    OK...So I just returned from shopping at Walmart and they were out of e.v.e.r.y. single carpet shampooer except for a very high end one I'm not interested in (it has a little removable hand held one with it). Bummer. I guess I'll have to try shopping another day....In the meantime, keep ...»

    commenting. I think we're all learning some important tips here ;-)

    Thanks all!

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Woodbridge Environmental ... Colonia, NJ
    Personally I would suggest renting the machine. You can get a much more powerful unit and not have to deal with all the issues with it not being cleaned properly. You can get several rentals out of the cost of one of the better units you would purchase.

    Now for the bad news.

    Using a carpet cleaning device can become a big issue for those who have allergies. I do not ...»

    care if you have the most expensive unit made. When water gets into the carpet fibers and the padding becomes damp, You begin to grow mold.

    When I am called out to do a mold audit on a house and the issue is kids are always sick. One of the very first things I check is the carpet. Using a device called a "carpet check" I vacuum a small devoted section of the carpet. Looking under a microscope it looks like one of those old Godzilla movies. All sorts of critters and mold spores present. Even in the cleanest of homes. If you add moisture to the carpet more then once a year your elevating your chance to have mold develop in great numbers.

    Have you ever seen them do a carpet drying when a flood occurs? They remove a small area off of the wall and place their fans under the padding and then use high pressure fans to push out the moisture. Simple vacuuming will not work. These fans cause the carpet to rise up like a balloon while high capacity air dryers are used to draw the humidity out when the fans run. Even using a high power shop vacuum that is designed to pick up water is not enough to remove the moisture fast enough to prevent mold from occurring.

    But if you do use these machines do not soak the carpet only spritz it lightly. Many machines on the market put out way to much water in a single pass.

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    @ Woodbridge. You make a great point here about carpet cleaning. And honestly I probably outta just hire it done because we don't have a lot of foot traffic that will cause overtly dirty carpets. Yes, they'll get dirty but as you say, not wet/moldy.

    Call me crazy but in our former house we put in new padding and carpet in our basement family room in 2000 and I only had to clean it once in all that time....and then I used a dry compound that ...»

    worked well. When we sold the house in February, the new owners looked at the carpet and said "Wow! You must have just had this cleaned!"

    Maybe I just outta call one of carpet cleaners soon. Any recommendations Woodbridge, as to which kind to call? We have some that use a truck mounted unit; some that do it all inside without the truck; some that use some sort of cleaner that they say dries in less than an hour.

    Suggestions? I think we'd all like to hear them. With the cost of carpeting these days, we're all interested in knowing how to take care of it the best way.

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Julie J C Saint Cloud, MN
    Love my Hoover steam vac. I have had up to 7 cats, a dog, two sons, and a husband, and this thing keeps on working!
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Shari Tampa, FL
    With pets (and now living on a horse farm), I have plenty of dirt to contend with so having my own steam carpet cleaner at my immediate disposal is an absolute must for me.

    I've owned 2 Bissell ProHeat machines and although they did a good job of cleaning, they didn't last much past the 1 year warranty date. Three years ago, I splurged and purchased a Hoover Platinum Collection steam cleaner. At almost $400, I'd venture to say it's probably one of the most ...»

    expensive consumer grade cleaners available but... it has a 6 year warranty. Yes, SIX years! Frankly, like the Bissell machines I've had in the past, the Hoover Platinum machine does have its share of mechanical pitfalls--I'm on my third Hoover Platinum machine in 3 years--but thanks to that 6 year warranty, Hoover has replaced and/or repaired them for free so I feel like I've already gotten my money's worth out of the machine... and I still have 3 more years left on my warranty. If the past 3 years are any indication of the next 3, I'm sure Hoover will be sending me at least 2 new machines during the remainder of my warranty period.

    I would recommend the Hoover Platinum machine based on the 6 year warranty alone but it really does an excellent job of cleaning too. I love that it has not only a tank for soapy water but it also has one for clean water, which is great for rinsing. (Soap residue attracts dirt so the more you can rinse out, the better.) The machine also has fantastic suction so my carpets dry very quickly, even though I do a lot of rinsing. Typically, by the time I'm done cleaning a couple rooms, the first area I cleaned is already dry.

    If your carpets aren't very dirty, or you don't need them cleaned often, you might decide hiring a carpet cleaning company, or renting a machine is the way to go for you. I've done both before. The carpet cleaning companies didn't really do that great of a job and most certainly didn't put much effort into getting the high traffic areas or tough spots clean. As far as renting goes...recently, when I was waiting for a replacement Platinum machine to be sent by Hoover, I rented a Rug Doctor machine and was NOT impressed. It was awkward and hard to manuver, it took twice the work because it cleaned only on the back stroke, and it had virtually no suction so my carpets were still wet the next day.

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Shari, I've heard that too about the Rug Doctor rentals. And get this---Some of my friends have talked about rental units and have been sorely upset because the previous renter of the machine didn't clean it out after use. And the resulting smell from the previous user's carpets ended up in their carpet. Eeeww!

    I am SO torn: Get my own machine or hire it done! Ugh!!!! What's a girl to do? :-) I'm ...»

    still going to shop for one tomorrow. I guess I'll decide when I see them on the shelves...if there are any there! Holy cow! Our whole town must be buying these things! Maybe it's cuz they're cleaning up after the oil boom workers ;-)

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Oh another thought: Our minister says he uses a non-commercial shampooer in the church. It has very low pile commercial carpeting. He says he never uses the shampoo...just the steam..and the carpets are always very clean looking. Ever heard anybody else doing this "method". You know that if the shampoo isn't extracted/cleaned out, it attracts dirt....sorta like if we don't get all the shampoo out of our hair. Or is this all an urban myth about the carpet shampooer?
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Shari Tampa, FL
    @ CNDesigns, yes believe me, when I rented the Rug Doctor machine, I couldn't help but wonder where it had been previously and what it had cleaned {{shudder}} but I was in a pickle and didn't have a lot of options...

    Personally, I add less soap to the tank than recommended and often just use the clean water rinse on less dirty areas. Also, if I have it on hand (which I usually do), I add white vinegar to ...»

    the clean water rinse tank to help cut the soap residue. Once, when I had one of my old Bissell machines plug up and not spray, the lady in the repair shop told me it would help to take the machine outside and run a tankful of hot water and white vinegar through it each time I was finished using the machine. She said the white vinegar would flush out all the little tubes and nozzles that tend to get plugged up with soap residue and dirt.

    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 1
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    @ Julie J C...You say you love your Hoover steam vac. But which model? There are several and they all have varying reviews.
    on Aug 02, 2012 · Like 0
  • Peggy C Chesapeake, VA
    That's it! After reading the previous comments I'm convinced I am not replacing the carpet in my house anymore... it will be hardwood for me! Carpet can only harbor the grossest of problems.
    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 1
  • Becky H Tampa, FL
    Peggy C., you are absolutely correct............carpet, no matter how clean you get it, holds allergens and all sorts of nasties that can influence health. I personally do not like carpet, after having it and cleaning it for 45 years. However, the hubby seems to prefer soft surfaces in the home. We've had an abundance of dogs over the years and children, so I'm familiar with all the carpet cleaning challenges. ...»

    Personally, I like to keep a can of "Spot Shot" on hand for small spot cleaning, reserving the Hoover for the complete carpet cleaning. Keys to a thorough cleaning are: pretreating spots and thorough rinsing after cleaning the carpets, with as complete extraction as possible. I spend so much time extracting during the cleaning, it's nuts, but my carpets are dry within 1 hr. afterwards. My philosophy is, if there's water, then there's dirt w/that water in the carpet. While I feel all carpet cleaners leave some dirt in the carpet, at least I know I got a good portion of the dirt out and have killed/removed dust mites at the same time.

    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 1
  • Jeanette S Atlanta, GA
    Hee, hee...I have to laugh at this one! Carpet cleaner? My favorite brand is "Hubby"...he calls a professional cleaner! We are going to try that "NO RES" one day. We have so little carpet...
    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 0
  • Terri J York, PA
    I have owned both a mid-grade and high end hoover - loved them both. A friend gave me a Bissell - hated it. Someone else swears by renting "Rug Doctore". I think once trick is to vacuum, vacuum and vacuum first. Second - spot treat any previous stains. Third - I personally love the small of simple green and green works, so I use those intsead of shampoo. If allergies are a concern, frind something small to sample chemical on - no reaction and no bleaching, try that. Cost of a pr or ...»
    enting a machine a couple times, often covers purchase of your own. Yes - theri are pros' who don't use water to carpet clean - can't remember the name of the product off hand, but safe to walk on right away.

    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Personally I wouldn't have carpet either! I so miss our hardwood in the former house {sniff, sniff}. I would use my little electric broom, then swiffer it (although I had a DIY version of that) and then use a little vinegar/water with another DIY wet swiffer to really clean it! It sparkled; it was clean; it was never full of "grossities" like I KNOW carpets harbor. Blech!

    With all that being said, I have to live with the carpet for now in our new home. Down the ...»

    road, it'll go! Honestly if we can't afford hardwood, even the peel and stick floor tiles look like a better deal to me!

    Jeanette---You are funny! Wonder if anyone out there will misread your comment and go looking in the Yellow Pages for "Hubby Carpet Cleaners". :-)

    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 0
  • Woodbridge Environmental ... Colonia, NJ
    As far as companies, I do not like any of them. Once you have them in your home they try to sell you everything under the sun. Their fine if your about to sell and want a complete cleaning, but for everyday use. I would simply rent a unit from the local rental store.

    Steer clear of those companies that use Dry chemical cleaning. It is simply impossible to remove all the chemicals that are applied in the fibers so some will always remain. Where do you think ...»

    that nice smell comes from. That is out-gassing of remaining chemicals and you do not want to breath that in as well.

    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Woodbridge---So you say rent a shampooer. How I can be sure I'm not putting other people's yuck back into my carpet from a previous renter's home? I've heard some awful stories about that! Help! My friend said she rented one and after using it, her carpet and home smelled awful! The machine had been returned without being cleaned by the previous renter or the store...yikes!
    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 0
  • Woodbridge Environmental ... Colonia, NJ
    The units have two containers. One that picks up the gunk the other that holds the cleaners and water. So what ever has been picked up prior simply is flushed away. The two never mix. So as long as the container that holds the cleaning chemicals and water is clean. your fine. Of course you need to check that the collection tank is clean also just to be sure your not dealing with someone elses stuff. ...»

    In any case it is no different then using a shop vacuum to clean the wood dust in the shop then using it to vacuum a carpet in the house. The dust will never see the carpet.

    Just be sure to rent it from a reliable rental store. And check its operation out before leaving. They will turn it on and run it., So if smells are an issue you will see (smell) that right off. But it is highly unlikely that you will get a machine from a reliable rental center that will not have been properly rinsed out. They make money from those who do not bring back machines clean. And charge them a lot to clean them. At least that is the case with those that are around my area.

    on Aug 03, 2012 · Like 1
  • Krista Williams Helena, MT
    Bought a Bissel like the one pictured on the post the other day and it sucks!!! Gonna see if Costco will take it back!!! I purchased a new one because my Hoovers brushes stopped working. I had to take my old one over the top to take out the water leftover from my new one!! The tank size on the Bissel is way to small and it is hard to tell when the water runs out!! And it was not all that simple to put together. And when you go to put the tank on you have to take this little head thing and ...»
    put the lip underneath (the directions did tell you to make sure do this), but it wasn't as simple as the instructions said. Not impressed at all!! By the time I got to actually shampoo the carpet I was very frustrated!! I will purchase another Hoover Dual V, lasted a long time and suffered a lot of wear and tear by letting my kids use it in their home. Sorry, I am done ranting now.

    on Feb 20, 2013 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    Krista, I just used my Bissel (like the one pictured above) again the other day and was verrrrry disappointed! It worked good the first time I used it several months ago. This time was only the second use ever and it spilled/leaked water SO much everywhere I was mopping it up off the kitchen floor before it ran through! (I had turned it on there because I wanted to use the hand shampooer attachment on a dining chair.)Then it dumped so much on the hallway carpet I literally worked in that ...»
    small area for about 4 hours trying to extract the water. I made sure everything was securely positioned and everything was cleaned out after the last use, so I have no idea why it worked so badly. Either there was something not working right or it brought up stain from the hardwood flooring underneath or God only knows what! Honestly it was a real head-scratcher! But then I worked the rest of the day to remove that weird stain! It was a total mess. It looks OK now but I'm wondering if any damage occurred to the hardwood underneath :-( I am so ready to remove the carpeting! But we can't take on another big project yet. We're completing our garage...and I don't want to be doing flooring work in the dead of winter. Sorry, now I'm done with my rant.

    on Feb 20, 2013 · Like 0
  • Connie Nikiforoff Designs Mandan, ND
    P.S. to my last comment: I'm SO ready for all hard surface flooring in our main living areas.... and on all the steps too! Even painted plywood subfloors are starting to look good ;-)
    on Feb 20, 2013 · Like 0

NOTE: You can drag and drop your photos to reorder them
Required
Comment Saving...

Related Posts

  • FALL Decorating..Remove sisal rugs & throw down cow hide, zebra print or shag rugs! 10 Ways to Decorate w/cow hide.
  • How to make a shaped upholstered headboard
  • Turn a tablecloth into a Floorcloth!
  • 1 Like

    Mary Rushing

Related Topics

Carpets, Rugs & Upholstery, Cleaning & Organization

Recent Questions »

  • Lynne
    How to get rid of well water stains
    4 hours ago 5 answers
  • Frankie Laney
    Vintage screen part two.
    6 hours ago 6 answers
  • Denise
    Can you get the smell out of a chest f...
    11 hours ago 5 answers
  • Have a question?
    Ask now & get answers»
Back
to top
Feedback