Thistle seed for finches wasted, help

Bernice H
by Bernice H
I have niger seed in socks and in a finch feeder, I also have about 2 inches of seed on the ground and all around this area. Any suggestion on how to contain these seeds so there is not so much wasted seed and money? There's gotta be a better way! yes?
  5 answers
  • Meredith bungard Meredith bungard on Oct 26, 2014
    I cut a slit in one of those cheap plastic pools for kids. Slipped the pole in the slit or if it.s hanging fron something just sit a nice decorative pot or something big enough under it.
  • Jackie Gfeller Jackie Gfeller on Oct 26, 2014
    I use the plastic thistle feeders and they work great, but the seed you see under the feeder is usually the empty seed casing. They often shell the husk off and eat the seed within. They do that with a lot of grains. I don't care for the socks, though, because they do drop a lot! Good luck.
    • Kat DiChiara Kat DiChiara on Sep 02, 2020

      You have given me hope, Jackie! I was SURE this hill under the feeder was real thistle (which is not cheap!). Thank you for answering!!!


  • Bernice H Bernice H on Oct 26, 2014
    Thanks for the input. I know the seed is not shells...stinkers, plus the wind whips the sock around and even the plastic feeder. Just touch it and out the seed falls. I have a wheelbarrow with flowers under the tree where the sock and feeder is, and it has a couple of inches of seed too. the feeders are about 5 ft up, a pool would not be very handy I think. plus the seed gets wet !
  • Carol Ann McDaniel Carol Ann McDaniel on Oct 27, 2014
    I have lots of wind and use a metal feeder I got at tractor supply. It's heaver, has a domed metat top, fine mesh sides and a small dish at the bottom. Works really well. I have it over bare ground and nothing gets down to sprout.
  • Jackie Gfeller Jackie Gfeller on Oct 28, 2014
    Niger Thistle seed is sterilized before it comes into the country, so it shouldn't ever sprout. Millet, though, which is in some mixes will. It is grown here in the states.