Stain over paint

I painted my fireplace and then put stain over it to deepen the color and wiped off the excess, but now the stain leaves an oily residue if you wipe over it. I want to put a poly top coat, but am afraid too. Help, what should I do?
Fireplace in my Family Room
  5 answers
  • K K on Feb 09, 2015
    You can use a polycrylic. I have used it over glazes and stains, too. My front door is a fiberglass door with wood grain pattern. I stained it and left it. When I restained it, I used polycrylic over it (poly doesn't yellow) and it is lasting longer and is easy to clean. Hope that helps!
  • CK CK on Feb 09, 2015
    I've stained over paint too. It takes an enormous amount of time for it to dry....but it will eventually. Leave it alone till it dries completely. Unfortunately you can't dust/clean it and it will probably get some of that into the stain till completely dry. I've found it's much easier to do a paint glaze over paint than use stain :-) If the stain is still damp you may (heavy emphasis on the word may!) be able to wipe it off then apply a darker paint glaze. I've never tried this but you might be able to try it in an inconspicuous area to see if it works.
    • See 4 previous
    • Cyndi Moore Tippett Cyndi Moore Tippett on Feb 10, 2015
      I don't have a grand, but we have a very nice piano that is two years old and was not played very much. My son is the piano player, but I love to hear him play. We too are blessed with our piano room, in our last house it was in the family room, not ideal. I LOVE your rooms, especially the lamp shades, they are precious. Your rooms look very inviting...
  • Melinda Lockwood Melinda Lockwood on Feb 09, 2015
    Use a water-based glaze. Brush on and wipe off to desired look. Let it dry and then clear coat it with a water-based polyurethane.
    • Cyndi Moore Tippett Cyndi Moore Tippett on Feb 09, 2015
      The problem is I already stained it with an oil based stain.... waiting for it to dry...it is getting there and then I am going to poly over it to seal it. I hope it works like I want it too...
  • Postcards From the Ridge Postcards From the Ridge on Feb 09, 2015
    I've also used oil based stain as a glaze over painted furniture. If it's rainy or damp in your area it will definitely take a couple of days to dry completely. I've topcoated it with both acrylic varnish and acrylic polyurethane. It shouldn't be any problem as long as the stain is completely dry. Good luck! Let us know how it turns out!
    • See 2 previous
    • Cyndi Moore Tippett Cyndi Moore Tippett on Feb 10, 2015
      Thank you so much for the advice.... I was able to poly it today and it looks wonderful and the finish is goregous. I used Minwax Oil-modified Polyurethane and it did great. Lowes guy told me it is water based but will give me the hard finish like the oil based. Very pleased with the results....
  • Vicki Hufford Vicki Hufford on Dec 06, 2015
    Switch from oil based to glazes for future projects. Big variety of colors, clean up with water, dries quickly & you can seal them if desired or leave it Matte. I Love glazes over top of paint as your desired effects are yours to determine.