How can I get the rust stains off of this 1950's metal lid?

Julie
by Julie
It was sitting with the lid upside down and exposed to indoor air for years. The metal is shiny like it is stainless steel yet it rusted. The metal on the lazy susan didn't rust at. See photos below
  13 answers
  • Leigh Rowan Leigh Rowan on May 22, 2015
    vinegar and/or baking soda is a natural scrubber. I have also used salt, but not knowing the coating that might not be good. I would also get a mr clean white scrubber.
  • Adell Adell on May 22, 2015
    You could try a cleaner called CLR, it is really good at cleaning a lot of things and I know it works on some things like it took off the rust from my bathroom sink and tub, that were Porecelin.
  • Renee Renee on May 22, 2015
    I've heard soaking in vinegar will remove rust...but I've not tried it
  • Della Annette Della Annette on May 22, 2015
    leigh is right....baking soda scrub with vinegar.
  • Swan Road Designs Swan Road Designs on May 22, 2015
    Don't want to be a wet blanket here but your lid could be aluminum and, if that's the case, all that you'll probably be able to do is to slightly diminish the pitted "feel" of the lid. As for the lazy susan, I'm pretty certain it is chrome and not at all the same metal as the lid.
  • Jill Jill on May 22, 2015
    Soak it in coca cola
  • Carol Potts Carol Potts on May 23, 2015
    I have used TarnX on items like this and it will clean it up.
  • 9530106 9530106 on May 23, 2015
    I use good old SOS pads for this type of thing. They will not scratch, but will remove the tarnish and rust. As others have said, there may still be some pitting that can't be removed.
  • Paul Gauthier Paul Gauthier on May 24, 2015
    It looks like it could be pitted, also. Some of the answers here are good ones and if you can get the heavy stuff off and find that it is certainly stainless steel, try some SOS pads. I use it all the time on stainless and it does NOT leave abrasive marks.
  • Ryta Power Ryta Power on May 24, 2015
    Have you tried a Magic Eraser. They truly are amazing!
  • Robin Miller Cresci Robin Miller Cresci on May 24, 2015
    I have heard that the acid in Cola will help treat rust. Its worth a try?!
  • Sue Monroe Sue Monroe on May 26, 2015
    My dad used Coca Cola to remove rust. He said it had to be the original Coke, not diet or other brands. I use Hydrogen Peroxide to remove rust around my bathroom sink faucet. Squirt a little on, let it bubble up & wipe it off when it gets loosened up. Doesn't harm the faucet.
  • Bert Miller Bert Miller on May 29, 2015
    Try WD-40 and a very fine steel wool. The WD-40 can be washed off. It is a rust remover.