Asked on Jul 07, 2015

Which chair should I go with in my newly redone master bedroom?

Reginaeaster
by Reginaeaster
So I just repainted my room this pretty revere pewter by Benjamin Moore..and I love it...
Plus hubby put in new batton board...soooooooooooo my question is should I go with the grey chair to the left or change the pattern on the chair to the right adding a deep grey linen to it (see second picture). EVENTUALLY I want to get rid of the carpet and add hardwood that matches the rest of the downstairs....sorry some of the photos aren't that clear...bad lighting .....thanks
left or right chair
this is the before room pic..I would love to add that gold mirror to the new design BUT not sure about mixing the silver and golds...
  25 answers
  • Ana Bacallao Ana Bacallao on Jul 07, 2015
    I like the gray chair in its simplicity much better for your new room. By the way why don't you get some metallic pewter paint that you could use in the mirror and wipe off so that the gold shows through too..
  • Johnathan Bing Johnathan Bing on Jul 07, 2015
    maybe reupholster the the second chair with a textured or lightly patterned similar shade of gray as the other, then trim the pillows with the same fabric to "marry" the look cohesive.
  • Trixie63 Trixie63 on Jul 08, 2015
    Dang girl you have a giant bedroom. It looks wonderful I love that BM grey. It is so great everywhere. I think grey chair not so much because of color but scale. You don't want a roller coaster room.
    • Reginaeaster Reginaeaster on Jul 08, 2015
      @Trixie63 yeah i like the grey but i think it might be a bit to small.......thanks
  • C-lo C-lo on Jul 08, 2015
    I don't think you could go wrong with either one. To me, the chair on the right seems to have more in common with your decor than the grey chair. Maybe pop up the color and reupholster it? If that's too much work, you can either paint the grey chair, change the pillow, or have it reupholstered (again, more work.) The easiest thing to do would be to get a new pillow for the grey chair. That would change everything. Good luck, you have a beautiful bedroom!!!
  • Debbie Miller Debbie Miller on Jul 08, 2015
    Definitely the one on the right! Beautiful Bedroom!
  • Rose Rose on Jul 08, 2015
    I prefer the left chair definately because of the style. The chair on the right doesn't have the clean lines like the rest of the room/furniture. D probably find another room to use it. I'd probably paint it a light color.
  • Diane Diane on Jul 08, 2015
    I like the chair on the right also...I think you have enough leather pieces in the room and need to add some softness...I would cover the chair in a fabric that brings out the blue in the spread..maybe a stripe or one that would complement the spread...you might want to buy some swatches from fabric store and see what looks best first before deciding..good luck...I really like your new wall color.
  • Lizzy L Lizzy L on Jul 08, 2015
    I would keep both chairs and the table, but with new upholstery. I would pull the blue color from the bedspread for the chair on the right. The chair on the left could be ok with just a colorful pillow on top. If it's just one chair or the other, the scale will be off. I would also replace the couch that's at the end of the bed with a beautiful upholstered bench. Possibly one with clear legs to give the room some airiness. Good job!
    • Reginaeaster Reginaeaster on Jul 09, 2015
      @Lizzy L great ideas...i haven't had the couch but a year or so ...so i might just put a slip cover on it....
  • Centrd Centrd on Jul 08, 2015
    Either one could work but since your lamps and leather chair are more contemporary, choosing the contemporary chair (on the left) would give the room a more updated traditional feel. The only problem I have with it is it looks slightly too small where it is. But the contemporary lines of the chair do create some balance with the more traditional bedroom furniture. On the other hand, I like the size and visual interest that's created with the open detail of the chair on the right. So if you prefer a more straight forward traditional look, then the chair on the right has a stronger traditional feel and the scale seems better. Really depends on what you like. If you're going for a more contemporary or casual feel, which it seems with the new bedding, board-and-batten and lamps, then you could change out the hardware on your furniture to give it a more updated traditional look, too. People are mixing metals these days, not sure about the gold of the mirror being so close to the silver lamps. But it can't hurt to try it out and see what you think. Or you could always buy some "Rub N Buff" and add some silver to the mirror to give it that antiquey silvery/gold feel that might work better with the lamps. Beautiful room, btw.
    • Reginaeaster Reginaeaster on Jul 09, 2015
      @Centrd thank you....i have decided to try some brushed gold lamps....just to see how it looks
  • Liz Weiss Liz Weiss on Jul 08, 2015
    I could with the right chair but cover it in lime green
  • ACoburn ACoburn on Jul 08, 2015
    I vote for the left chair. I takes up less space visually.
  • Heather B Heather B on Jul 08, 2015
    The transformation is beautiful! Would you mind sharing where you found your bedspread?
  • Sheila Sheila on Jul 08, 2015
    I would use the chair on the right. The scale of it goes better with the bed. The one on the left is too small.
  • Terry Terry on Jul 08, 2015
    Regina I like the chair on the left but with a patterned pillow on it. Maybe that one that is on your bed or pick up a small patterned pillow with that lovely green from your coverlet on the bed. That is my favorite colour and it is all through my house.
  • B. Enne B. Enne on Jul 08, 2015
    Nice room! Left chair...better scale, goes better with your room and less "dining room-y". They are both great chairs BTW.
  • Nancee Nancee on Jul 08, 2015
    Left chair. A pillow with more color might be nice. Right chair is nice but looks like it belongs in the dining room. Beautiful bedroom!
  • Susan Patterson Mayes Susan Patterson Mayes on Jul 08, 2015
    Not answering in order of questions but it is perfectly fine to mix metals, I might even add a third metal in a decorative object ( rule of three) the chair on the right appears to be better in scale with bed, etc, so I would reuphoster the seat with a color fabric that coordinates with bedding ensemble to give a pop of color and add interest. Then maybe do coordinating throw pillows for other chairs n sofa. Also if you don't use all that seating I would edit some out of the room to give the room a more spacious quality.
  • Katrina Warren Katrina Warren on Jul 08, 2015
    @Reginaeaster I like the grey chair on the left. Lovely makeover!
  • Whomping Willow Whomping Willow on Jul 08, 2015
    This is gorgeous, even the before picture is great! No idea about the chair:)
  • Doreen Dwviniczuk Doreen Dwviniczuk on Jul 08, 2015
    I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE, your bedspread, where did you get it? I would like it for my bedroom.
  • Cynthia H Cynthia H on Jul 08, 2015
    I personally like the gray chair. There's just something so soothing about gray that seems perfect in your lovely bedroom.
  • Drprof Drprof on Jul 09, 2015
    If you decide to use the chair on the right, what about black suede?(or suede cloth) or using an animal print????
  • Drprof Drprof on Jul 10, 2015
    I thought that it would hake up your room a bit. What a beautiful job Mary
  • Terry Terry on Jul 21, 2015
    Oh Regina, when you said not sure of mixing silver and gold so you could add the mirror. All designers are doing that now. I think it would look nice. Things don't have to be matchy anymore. Your room looks beautiful.
    • Reginaeaster Reginaeaster on Jul 22, 2015
      @Terry thank you....i ended up changing the lamps to brushed gold and added a brush gold mirror...i love it more
  • Debi53 Debi53 on Jul 21, 2015
    You have done a lovely redo of your room. It looks like you have room for both chairs. Why not instead of covering them in grey, paint the wooden parts of both in a beautiful shade of grey and cover the fabric areas on both chairs in a green & white trellis fabric to go with the floral pattern in your comforter? Definitely use your gold mirror if you love it. Just add a few more touches of gold around your room to tie it in--a gold vase, dish, bookends, picture frame, or even spray your flowerpot gold or add a gold edge to it. I don't mean do all these things in gold, just a few.