« View Post
Photos

Oops! Leave without saving?

If you leave this page, the information you have entered will not be saved!
Are you sure you want to leave this page?

Leave this page Stay on this page

Hometalk.com

  • Sign Up
  • or
  • Log In
  • Professionals
  • Community
    • All Members
    • Professionals
    • Bloggers
  • About
    • About Hometalk
    • Blog
    • FAQ
    • Guidelines
    • Resources
    • Support
    • Press
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
  • Following
  • All Topics
    • Cleaning & Organization
    • Crafts
    • Design & Décor
    • DIY Projects
    • Gardening
    • Home Maintenance & Repairs
    • Outdoor Living
    • Painting
    • Remodeling
    • Repurposing & Upcycling
    See More Topics »
  • Questions
    • All Questions
    • Open Questions
    • Unanswered Questions
  • Clips
Post & Ask
Join Now

Get advice, inspiration and feedback on all your home & garden projects!

17
Becky J
Becky J Troy, IL on Feb 03, 2013
Like Clip

Lombardy Poplars

This is a "warning" post. I had planted a row of these about 4 years ago, with the intention of blocking out the neighbor behind us. Our 6 foot privacy fence, on a slope, was only about 5 feet in reality. True to their information, they do grow extremely fast and provide excellent privacy. Within 3 years they were about 15 feet tall.

Unfortunately, we spent last summer trying to exterminate them. The roots are VERY invasive. I found a root up against our above ground pool, and my pool means much more to me than privacy. I didn't need roots poking up through the vinyl liner.

The way we got rid of them was to cut them down, and then spend the entire summer applying TORDON stump killer to the shoots. There were shoots everywhere, even 15 feet up into the yard, in every direction. The drought we had last year was a blessing in disguise for us, because it helped in preventing more roots, since they like water. Tordon works fantastically in immediately killing the shoot.

So, if you like these and want to plant, I would suggest you do it out on the back 40 where it won't bother anything.

  • Like Clip
Post Comment | Like | Clip | Share
34950 Views
74 Comments Displaying 25 of 74 comments | See Previous
  • Vicki R
    Everytime I find a poplar twig growing in my yard I dig it up. This Spring I plan to remove a small trumpet vine. They're growing everywhere at my Mom's with one covering a 30 foot pine tree. Also, must dig up a Locust tree which took root near my property line last Spring and grew to 8 foot tall by Fall. I'd thought about keeping it for it's fast growth & privacy but it has huge thorns everywhere.
    on Feb 06, 2013 · Like 0
  • Brian Karth Sheboygan, WI
    To Nicolette, DO NOT USE TORDON ON LAWNS UNLESS YOU WANT TO POLLUTE YOUR SOIL AND GROUNDWATER!!! Please use a grass and weed killer available at your local garden center. They will be more than happy to help you in that area. Can we get of the Tordon subject please, their is too much misuse of this product, it is scary. Thanks.
    on Feb 06, 2013 · Like 6
  • Sondra A Janesville, WI
    Brian, while I have never used, nor ever heard of, Tordon, thank you for all the warnings. It will definitely stick in my mind should I be moseying around that part of a store.
    on Feb 06, 2013 · Like 3
  • Lisalynn Missouri Valley, IA
    Oh that's too bad.. perhaps the warning should be To consult a local landscaper first.

    we absolutly LOVE ours .. in fact we start new trees from the 5 yr olds. They are wonderful for a wind break , we planted 2 or three rows of them along with the Blue Spruce.. LOVE them.. as someone said they can be kept under control by pruning..

    In fact I prune them the first 2 yrs to keep the base more compact , making for a more solid ...»

    tree at ground level. but then we have 30 acres , so we do have room to roam.

    on Feb 10, 2013 · Like 2
  • Sharon Marks Danbury, CT
    We had bamboo in our yard for years. The dang stuff grew everywhere!! Spread like wild fire and we are still pulling them up every summer. Worse thing ever but we didn't plant them our neighbor did on our border. VERY invasive as are morning glories but they were easier to control once we began taking off all the seed pods in the fall and picking up any we saw on the ground. We have 3 butterfly bushes and so far have had no problem.
    on Feb 10, 2013 · Like 2
  • Nita O Ridgeley, WV
    My sister keeps insisting forsythia is invasive but I wish mine would spread more :-( Horrible neighbor.
    on Feb 10, 2013 · Like 4
  • Becky J Troy, IL
    Nita, too funny! I love forsythia! I used to have a whole hedge of it at my other house. It was great for privacy, but I got tired of trimming it. My husband wouldn't let me grow it the way it was meant.....weeping. (It touched his truck.....oh no!)
    on Feb 11, 2013 · Like 4
  • Bernice H Yakima, WA
    hmm This is an interesting thread, manyof the orchards here plant Aussie willows.. I think that is what they are called. They grow sooo fast, used for windbreaks. (some times they are interspersed with slower growing trees), we have a friend who used them around their many acres. IAPPRECIATE VERY MUCH the advice to check with arboretum or county extension. we did not and planted a "krauter plum?" many years ago, every spring it is like a buffet for aphids, then they go away. and have very ...»
    annoying suckers too! grr The other tree we planted was a 'sunburst locust'? these are too big for a mobile home park, so every year we are trimming,and the locust is not easy to prune and get a decent shape..at least for us. So if ever doing this again, I will certainly take to heart..."go to the experts", not necessarily the nurseries! Good thread!

    on Feb 11, 2013 · Like 1
  • Connie K Kennesaw, GA
    Becky, Crepe Myrtle will grow tall, at least here in Georgia, but make certainly you really, really want it because it is also extremely hard to kill and its roots really spread so make certain it isn't anywhere near a driveway, foundation, sidewalk, etc. The previous owners of our house planted several within feet of the house and we have spent years getting rid of them. All it takes is one little piece of root. I've had them come back after 3 years time. That said, at my previous home I ...»
    had two that were two stories tall and very full. They were absolutely gorgeous but did a job on the driveway. I'd love to have them planted at the back of a lot though because they are truly beautiful. I agree with Bernice that checking with a local source like the extension service is a good idea. Also, local garden clubs are a great source because one of the members has usually tried what you are questioning. Personally, I like using more than one type of tree in a windbreak or screen. That way, if you loose one it isn't as obvious as in a line of trees that are all the same.

    on Feb 11, 2013 · Like 1
  • Gwen Campbell
    When my mom and I first moved to this place, she found a deal on some poplars that were supposed to make fast shade. They didn't lie about that, except for a few of the trees that grew straight up instead of spreading the limbs for shade. Then, the leaves started falling in the summer, so no shade. Now we are fighting the new trees coming up as far away from the original trees as 20 to 30 feet. No where in the as did they tell you the roots spread like this or that they would put out new ...»
    trees. We can barely keep the trees cut down. I am planning on cutting the main trees down, but hate to go back to having no trees in the yard.

    on Feb 12, 2013 · Like 0
  • Edith Sandy Lake, PA
    these are also a very soft wood and can come down in high winds .. i had one come threw my roof . one night when the winds were high
    on Feb 17, 2013 · Like 0
  • Lisa Guadagnoli Des Moines, IA
    These would be good for eroding river banks to save land from sliding into rivers.
    on Feb 17, 2013 · Like 1
  • Martha Hinkle Tecumseh, OK
    Sounds like Kudzu . . nice looking, fast growing vine . . . that TAKES OVER and chokes out everything, including trees.
    on Feb 17, 2013 · Like 0
  • Sherri B Stevens, PA
    Farmers around here talk about using copper nails to kill trees they didn't want. Anyone know if that indeed is true? Maybe that would work and not destroy the underground waters....
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Kathy Ranum Brainerd, MN
    DO NOT USE TORDON ON LAWNS UNLESS YOU WANT TO POLLUTE YOUR SOIL AND GROUNDWATER!!! Please use a grass and weed killer available at your local garden center. They will be more than happy to help you in that area. Can we get of the Tordon subject please, their is too much misuse of this product, it is scary As with all retardant's .. one should consider the area applied to and going to a local expert first for info ... just sayin
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Becky J Troy, IL
    Kathy Ranum not sure where you are getting that I was using it on the grass. it was applied to the poplars only. Unfortunately, they were coming up in the grass, so not much you can do about that.
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 1
  • Deborah D Cuba City, WI
    To Berneice...Austrees....we have them and planted about 10 years ago...they are full grown trees, you can literally stick a branch in the ground and it will grow! We planted away from the home and they are in no where's land and doing well.
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Candace Seaton Huntsville, AL
    Once again, a plant suffers because people are too lazy to do their homework or too cheap to ask an expert for advice...I hear this all the time..."How do I keep my (some tree meant to grow to 25') at 3 feet high?"
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Becky J Troy, IL
    Candace, height was never the problem. I adored these until they threatened the above ground pool. They were perfect to block out the neighbors. I have been planting for years and years. Some things are not meant to be.
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Shirley M
    Poplars are notorious for shoots! Our neighbour planted Swedish Columnar Aspen (also poplars) for the same reason you planted your poplars and the roots were soon near our foundation! I was forever trying to get rid of the shoots. Like your poplars, this wasn't a problem until they reached 20 feet in height. They are fast growing as well, growing 3-4 feet a year. It's the perfect plant for screening on an acreage. I blogged about my love/hate relationship with Swedish Columnar Aspen on The Gardening Life, my blog.

    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Barb Ross Apex, NC
    This will be the perfect tree to block out the highway behind my house. Luckily I have about 40 ft of pines between back yard and the road. Think I will plant them right at my property edge amongst the pines.
    on Feb 18, 2013 · Like 0
  • Judy Fleming Kingston, TN
    I have the same problem and have volunteer shoots 20' away under a gravel driveway. Hope to get them (original trees) cut down for firewood this summer.

    As far as not getting advice, tree catalogs don't give any warning.

    on Feb 22, 2013 · Like 1
  • Patricia Baker Lancaster, KY
    I have heard they grow fast but they also die fast. is this true?
    on Mar 06, 2013 · Like 0
  • Douglas Hunt New Smyrna Beach, FL
    They rarely live longer than 20 years, Patricia. That's a very short-lived tree.
    on Mar 07, 2013 · Like 1
  • Verlee Deana Norris Jenki... Clinton, AR
    Yes, Douglas, that is what I was going to add...they are short-lived. Guess that's why they send up so many shoots!
    on Apr 25, 2013 · Like 0

NOTE: You can drag and drop your photos to reorder them
Required
Comment Saving...

Related Posts

  • Garden decor
  • Gardening
  • My Proudest DIY?
  • 36 Likes

    Madelyn Urso Candy J Cindy buchanan Cynthia  Busch MarriePierrette Delana Elliott Morrison Darlene Patsy Betty Jo G Dorothy W Sharon Tillman Merry D Linda Logan
    +23 more

Clipped to 19 Boards »

  • Becky
    Garden Ideas
    by Becky
  • Miriam I
    Gardening tips
    by Miriam I
  • Ann Seymour
    Dream Yard
    by Ann Seymour

Related Topics

Gardening

Recent Questions »

  • Admiranda De Morton
    How does one make money via gar...
    18 minutes ago 17 answers
  • Katy
    Need to get rid of this!
    30 minutes ago 38 answers
  • Have a question?
    Ask now & get answers»
Back
to top
Feedback