TheLastLeafGardener
TheLastLeafGardener
  • Hometalker
  • New York, NY

Rain OR Shine Bird Feeders: To Perch, or NOT, May Be the Question!


My name is Patricia Youngquist, aka The Last Leaf Gardener. I am writer, urban gardener, birder and visual artist living in New York City. My garden can be seen in the photo one accompanying this entry. I am honored to have been contacted by Alex of Hometalk.com to post this entry re bird-feeders in urban gardens.
Although I have been gardening for a number of years, I am fairly new to birding, an interest which began this past summer as a result of my discovering a lone female cardinal (photo two) visiting my garden.
I have named the cardinal Cam, and even though an array of wild birds (including her beau, Mac (seen with her in photo three) visit it.
I confess that I'm partial to Cam. Hence, I've been on a mission to accommodate her "dining" needs with the "right" feeder! This post is about two feeders which I had thought would be the answer to my quest. The first of these feeders is one I've called a CB feeder after an extraordinarily helpful birder. It is pictured in photo four.
As you can see, the feeder has a canopy, and I had thought by lowering it, the smaller birds, such as my house finches, and cardinal couple, could eat in peace: without competing for food from my larger birds such as the occasional common grackles and ever present mourning doves!
And even though the smaller birds were the only sized ones who could ultimately avail themselves of the food from there, Cam and Mac stayed away from the CB feeder entirely; even though it was "designed" for them!
Moreover, the mourning doves learned to tip the feeder by sitting on top of it and then nosh on the seeds which fell from it! The main problem with this was the seeds fell on to the lush foliage of my kiwi vines which was quickly becoming full of holes from the birds eating seeds that landed on it!
And so, whilst I was researching for alternative places to hang the "CB" in my garden, I came across a slogan that truly spoke to me: "Nature happens. We cannot MAKE natural things happen (or NOT happen)." Upon reading it, I laughed at my efforts re the taking care of the "things" I grow in my garden, as well as accommodating those who visit it!
As it turned out, the aforementioned slogan is from a place that sells — you guessed it — bird feeders! I contacted the place to tell them of my plight with Cam (as well as Mac), and was informed that perhaps the perches of my feeders had not been ones to my cardinals' liking; and they sold me an alternative feeder, a feeder that boasted perches which cardinals are comfortable with, and I now call that particular one a WBUSS feeder.
But since I had only viewed the WBUSS feeder via a virtual tour, I had no idea that it was "tower" shaped (just like my CB feeder), and now I was left with two feeders that I did not have a place for!
Be that as it may, I eventually came up with a brilliant idea of using the pole of a broom as a stake from which to hang either feeder, and inserted it into my kiwi vine's container. (Photo Five.)
The WBUSS feeder is an attractive addition to my garden, however, neither Cam, nor Mac, in spite of having access to a feeder with a perch to meet their needs, would nosh from it!
The finches seemed comfortable feeding from the WBUSS as seen in photos six through eight.
And the mourning doves opted for their standard behavior of staring-at-others-eating from a feeder they can't access, which you can see in the images nine and ten.
Even the bluejays checked out the WBUSS feeder too, as seen in pictures eleven through thirteen.
But Cam stayed clear: preferring to scrounge around on my garden's surface, and nibbling on crumbs that had fallen to the floor! (Seen in images fourteen through seventeen).
Or she merely ate from where "crumbs" have been dropped in to the containers of the "things" I grow! (Pictures eighteen and nineteen.) And while Cam continues to be satisfied eating this way, I've not seen Mac for a few days! I miss him!
In any event, what's a gardener/birder to do with only one "working pole" from which to hang two tower-style feeders to accommodate everyone!
Switch them around in rain is the answer! Now, it (my garden) is like an outdoor cafe; one feeder (the CB) has an awning for them in case of showers (pictures eighteen through twenty-one); the other is open-air in case the birds want to work on a suntan while they eat! (Images twenty-two and twenty-three.)
Of course when you switch out the feeders, it's a great time to clean the one not being used, but, no matter how hard you try to meet a bird's perching needs, like my little Cam, they may still prefer to eat the crcrumbs that fall to the floor, or better still have someone feed them as seen below! (Photo twenty-four.)
Aerial View of my Garden. (Referred to as Photo-One in post.)
Aerial View of my Garden. (Referred to as Photo-One in post.)
Cam, my visiting cardinal! (Referred to as Photo-Two in post.)
Cam, my visiting cardinal! (Referred to as Photo-Two in post.)
Cam and her beau Mac! (Referred to as Photo-Three in post.)
Cam and her beau Mac! (Referred to as Photo-Three in post.)
My CB feeder in its first locale! Note the lone mourning dove atop the feeder as he/she stares shamelessly ay my visiting house finches! (Referred to as Photo-Four in post.)
My CB feeder in its first locale! Note the lone mourning dove atop the feeder as he/she stares shamelessly ay my visiting house finches! (Referred to as Photo-Four in post.)
My WBUSS Feeder with supported by my "genius" pole idea! (Referred to as Photo-Five in post.)
My WBUSS Feeder with supported by my "genius" pole idea! (Referred to as Photo-Five in post.)
Male House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Six in post.)
Male House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Six in post.)
Male House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Seven in post.)
Male House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Seven in post.)
Female House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Eight in post.)
Female House Finch Has No Problem With WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Eight in post.)
A lone mourning dove opts for his/her shameless staring at "others" eating! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Nine in post.)
A lone mourning dove opts for his/her shameless staring at "others" eating! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Nine in post.)
A lone mourning dove opts for his/her shameless staring at "others" eating! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Ten in post.)
A lone mourning dove opts for his/her shameless staring at "others" eating! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Ten in post.)
A lone bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Eleven in post.)
A lone bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Eleven in post.)
A youngster-bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! View One.  (Referred to as Photo-Twelve in post.)
A youngster-bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Twelve in post.)
A youngster-bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Thirteen in post.)
A youngster-bluejay checks out WBUSS Feeder! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Thirteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Fourteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Fourteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Fifteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View Two. (Referred to as Photo-Fifteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View Three. (Referred to as Photo-Sixteen in post.)
Cam STILL prefers the crumbs that fall to the floor! View Three. (Referred to as Photo-Sixteen in post.)
Cam ALSO prefers the crumbs that fall to in the containers of what I grow! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Seventeen in post.)
Cam ALSO prefers the crumbs that fall to in the containers of what I grow! View One. (Referred to as Photo-Seventeen in post.)
Cam ALSO prefers the crumbs that fall to in the containers of what I grow! ViewTwo. (Referred to as Photo-Eighteen in post.)
Cam ALSO prefers the crumbs that fall to in the containers of what I grow! ViewTwo. (Referred to as Photo-Eighteen in post.)
CB Feeder is a great place to nosh in the rain (if you are a small bird) even IF a mourning dove stares at you! (Referred to as Photo-Nineteen in post.)
CB Feeder is a great place to nosh in the rain (if you are a small bird) even IF a mourning dove stares at you! (Referred to as Photo-Nineteen in post.)
Two female house finches enjoy noshing in the rain. (Referred to as Photo-Twenty in post.)
Two female house finches enjoy noshing in the rain. (Referred to as Photo-Twenty in post.)
Two may be company BUT three is NOT a crowd when finches nosh at CB Feeder in the rain! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-One in post.)
Two may be company BUT three is NOT a crowd when finches nosh at CB Feeder in the rain! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-One in post.)
Female House Finch works on her tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Two in post.)
Female House Finch works on her tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Two in post.)
Male House Finch works on his tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Three in post.)
Male House Finch works on his tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Three in post.)
Mac Feeds Cam! No wonder she doesn't want to perch from the CB OR WBUSS! Female House Finch works on her tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Four in post.)
Mac Feeds Cam! No wonder she doesn't want to perch from the CB OR WBUSS! Female House Finch works on her tan when noshing at WBUSS Feeder! (Referred to as Photo-Twenty-Four in post.)

Top Hometalk Projects

16 Creative Ways To Upcycle Pallets
23 DIY Wall Clocks That'll Transform Your Whole Room
17 DIY Decor Ideas To Get The Party Started
27 Gorgeous Update Ideas For Your Bedroom
18 Fun Ways To Add Glitter To Your Home Decor
15 Pieces Of Furniture That DIYers Built From Scratch
23 DIY Wall Clocks That'll Transform Your Whole Room
16 Ways to Showcase Your Herb Garden
30 Ways To Use Old Jeans For Brilliant Craft Ideas
30 Essential Hacks For Cleaning Around Your Home
30 Creative Ways To Repurpose Baking Pans
17 DIY-Inspiring Kitchen Backsplashes
31 Creative Garden Features Perfect For Summer
14 Cool Ways To Upholster Chairs That You Can DIY
21 Totally Terrific Things You Can Do With Doilies
TheLastLeafGardener

Want more details about this and other DIY projects? Check out my blog post!

Go

Have a question about this project?

Join the conversation

2 of 98 comments
  • Cherie Wallace
    on Jul 4, 2013

    That's nice you wrote about her and kept a log on her.I told u about me cleaning the feeder and putting some new black sunflower seeds in it. I had several cardinals on the feeder today, many, many times throughout the day. And she was out there somewhere cuz I could here her. She chirps soooo loudly and hangs around quite a bit. I just love to hear her.....Yes I am also glad I have you to discuss the cardinals with. I have learned some things from you and to that I want to thank-you. till next time....

  • Rebecca Cooks
    on Jun 28, 2016

    Any idea for a bird feeder in my window. No trees around. Live on ground level apt. Tried feeder with suction cups and didn't stay. Placed some Elmer's glue and waited then put birdfeeder that came with the kit and it fell also. Tried to find the long shephards cane with a lip to hold one and can't find one tall enough. Winters get very cold in south Dakota birds need food and shelter....help

Your comment...