I am looking for some suggestion on what I should do with my buffet

I would love to know what you think of my buffet! It needs some love and I am trying to decide whether to paint it or just try to restore the natural wood. Please click the link to my blog to see pictures of the dining room, where the buffet is located. I tried to attch pictures but couldn't not get them to upload for some reason.
  21 answers
  • KathrynElizabeth Etier KathrynElizabeth Etier on Feb 06, 2014
    With the details, this is a great candidate for painting, using complementary colors. Or painting and using wallpaper on the inside "panels".
  • So much great 'architecture' -- make sure if you paint that you highlight the trim - either with a different color or by sanding or masking the trim and letting it stand out. It's a lovely piece with loads of potential!
  • Lynn Crider Lynn Crider on Feb 07, 2014
    I just painted a similar buffet in Old Navy by Benjamin Moore. It turned out beautiful!!
  • 117135 117135 on Feb 07, 2014
    Restore the top to its natural wood and stain in a dark color. Paint the bottom with a great neutral color or light tone and use a dark glaze of dark wax to bring out the accents and trim.
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Feb 08, 2014
    Nikki, did you see the piece similar to yours, painted in glossy black? It is so elegant and classy. She used oil paint ..and explained why. You might check it out to see if you like it. I see so much shabby chippy stuff lately, and this is so beautiful.
    • Jeanette S Jeanette S on Feb 08, 2014
      @Bernice H I was going to suggest this solution too. It takes more work using oils and sanding between coats, but it is well worth it. Personally, I would give this piece a really good cleaning...use a damp cloth to rub it down. Then I would get some dark Old English oil and give it several coats....even using a cover stick if necessary. Then I would use several coats of varnish on it...I use rub on varnish. (You can find this at some paint stores or on line.)
  • Bernice H Bernice H on Feb 08, 2014
    Actually nikki, I clipped the picture in case you cant find it, or Miriam can help you find it. check my "clips" ......I guess that is how to pass something on.
  • Katie Katie on Feb 08, 2014
    I would clean and sand it first. Then you might consider painting it the same colour as chairs, staining the top of it. You might consider a matte finish, rather than glossy. It's a little less formal looking that way. You may want to paint the mirror overtop as well.
  • Paula prislovsky Paula prislovsky on Feb 08, 2014
    Paint using Annie Sloan chalk paint. You will fall in love with this piece!
  • Linda Linda on Feb 08, 2014
    I would definitely paint it, in a color you love. I had an 80's bookcase and an oak display cabinet, which I painted to match my new craft room, it was hard to put the first paint on but I love them now and before they was just so-so. I am in love with turquoise right now but what ever is going to make you happy is the advice I always give my friends. I put liquid sandpaper on to dissolve the finish, was so easy, just "painted" it on with a brush and they were ready to paint. Good luck be sure to post your results!
  • I would hesitate on painting it since it is in such good shape. I love the look of a painted piece of furniture, HOWEVER, your wood is in good shape so my suggestion would be to clean it up, restore the finish, and then for some added pizzaz I would change out the knobs/handles or give the existing ones an update with paint or rub-n-buff.
  • Opal Opal on Feb 08, 2014
    I would also hesitate to paint. I would clean up and restore the finish and then stain the rims a different color to accent the great lines of this piece. If you are looking for more color and are on the fence about painting, maybe change out some of the accessories for stronger colors. The existing color would look great with bolder jewel tone colors.
  • Christine Olson Christine Olson on Feb 08, 2014
    chalk paint would look good.
  • Adrianne C Adrianne C on Feb 09, 2014
    Put a sink in it and put it in the bathroom...
  • Nancy Hatcher Nancy Hatcher on Feb 09, 2014
    It looks like some of the accent trim on the bottom doors are missing. I would remove the rest of the trim on just the bottom doors and refinish using a wood stain that would match the rest of your furniture. It has beautiful lines!
  • BeBetsy BeBetsy on Feb 09, 2014
    My sister received a furniture piece just like this from my grandmother. It was in excellent condition so she replaced the top with a beautiful piece of green marble - OMG beautiful!
  • Colleen Colleen on Feb 09, 2014
    Do you know where you'll put this when done(Kitchen, Living room, Bathroom)? I like the idea of replacing the top with marble, and staining the wood a dark stain, then buff up the hardware. This looks like it'll be an amazing piece.
    • @Colleen It is currently in my dining room, and that is where it is staying. I would love to replace the top with marble, but that probably isn't in the budget, But great idea!
  • Mabeline Mabeline on Feb 15, 2014
    I would restore, but accentuate the raised line detail on the front of each drawer, making the details pop and more interesting. It is a beautiful buffet.
  • Joyce Nelson Shellhart Joyce Nelson Shellhart on Feb 16, 2014
    Look for a counter top installer in your area. You could be surprised at the deal you might get for a "cast off" piece of stone...also check for a building material recycler in your area.
  • Sandra Hellewell Sandra Hellewell on Mar 27, 2014
    Your buffet is lovely! I would use Restore-A-Finish on it & then wax & buff it. I think you'd be surprised with the results! I would NOT change the handles as they make the piece!! I might spray paint them gold & then when dry do a very light spray of silver paint on top just to vary the color a bit. Also I would paint the mirror so you have some contrast with the buffet. Right now, it all kind of blends because it's all the same! Good Luck!!
  • MaryAnn B MaryAnn B on Jul 23, 2014
    My opinion, since I own some similar to this. Briwax makes a product that is colored. it will cover the imperfections. first go over the scratched spots with Minwax colored pen, look in the paint store for this then wax. Only paint if you like the look.
  • Patches Patches on Jul 24, 2014
    This is a really fine looking piece! It would be gorgeous if you could restore it so the grain of the wood shows up. But that's just me because I love period furniture.