Can a chimney be removed from the roof line?

Hi Lrw1543,

From what I've seen and experienced in my home, the furnace exhaust pipe does not go through my fireplace, even though the both come out the chimney. In my opinion, it would be safer to have the chimney repointed and/or sealed where it is leaking. Also consider your town/city/county protocol for this situation to make sure it follows the codes. One more thing is to check with your insurance company. We had a few cracks in our chimney's mortar and our insurance company required us to repair it in order to keep our homeowners insurance. Wishing you the best.

OMG, yes.

Call a heating pro. It is possible your furnace can be vented through your foundation with some modifications. For that matter, call two or three pros for estimates/opinions. Only after that is done right can you move forward to a roofer and someone to disassemble the chimney And seal it below the roofline.

Here is a video that might be helpful - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M5D5DDHk_Hs

this is tremendously expensive to do. I know..I just had 5 quotes. Decided to NOT do it.

Expansive proposition. It can be removed leaving the vent pipe for the furnace in place. The opening patched around the furnace vent. The furnace vent pipe would need to be a solid pipe. Flashing for the pipe installed and the roof patched. Very costly. Cheapest would be to have the chimney inspected and repaired if possible.

Thank you. I appreciate your advice.

Maybe all you need is new flashing at where the chimney meets the roof and a chimney cap.