Asked on Dec 18, 2014

Please give me your opinions on these.

Beth McGareyDonna FieldsSusan
+120

Answered

I finally got the E6000 to hold my candy canes. I needed something stable in the middle so I glued 2 pieces of cardboard together and painted it red and glued to the back. The color is cherry red and a little darker than the canes so I thought about placing extra pieces of candy around it so I took a pic of one with and one without. So tell me what looks better please. Also where should I tie a ribbon to hang it with. It's going to be a little fragile but if it's not man handled I think it will work? Thank you.
109 answers
  • Gail@Purple Hues and Me
    Gail@Purple Hues and Me
    on Dec 18, 2014

    Cute, cute, cute! I like the extra pieces in the center and I would place the hanger in the middle of the back where it's the most stable. You could tie a long ribbon from there to hang it.

  • Lee Cunningham Green
    Lee Cunningham Green
    on Dec 18, 2014

    I love it, anything holiday.. I think a ribbon or Giant Bow to make it festive but wonderful job!

  • Valerie Binninger
    Valerie Binninger
    on Dec 19, 2014

    super cute

  • L
    L
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Love both but maybe the top one just a little bit more! I agree with Gail and her idea of hanger position. So sweet (no pun intended) and pretty! ;-)

  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Thank you all. It's my second crafty thing I've done. The first one was for my 8yr old niece for school. That one turned out pretty darn good. I'm more partial to the top one. I was just a little leery about the cardboard pieces and the paint. I was thinking about trying to sell it. What do you think and what would I ask. Candy canes are cheap and I'm not worried too much about my time,I'm disabled now and at home a lot.

  • Zelda McFarlane
    Zelda McFarlane
    on Dec 19, 2014

    I liked the second one best. I don't think a bow would look right on it. Hanging it with a ribbon would be my choice.

  • Judy Loy
    Judy Loy
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Really nice job! They are both excellent!!!

  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Thank you. I hope the next one goes a lot faster than this one.LOL.. practice makes perfect,so I hear.

  • Dianna Flowers
    Dianna Flowers
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Not sure how it would look but you could also use the green and white peppermint rounds too. Just a thought!!

  • Paulette Montoya
    Paulette Montoya
    on Dec 19, 2014

    I like the second one better. Maybe add a few more starlite mints to the center also. great job!

  • Diane Waddups
    Diane Waddups
    on Dec 19, 2014

    On the center instead of mints I glued a glittery, plastic snowflake. I left the cardboard on the back white. Then put the hanging ribbon around two canes at top to hang. Hung well and this is the second year I've used it.

  • Kathi Mureen
    Kathi Mureen
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Both are cute, but I like the second one best.

  • Kathy McDaniel
    Kathy McDaniel
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Wonderful, how did you get them evenly spaced for a 5pt star.

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Kathy McDaniel it took me awhile to get it right. I finally ended up laying the candy canes out on a piece of cardboard and marking where I wanted them with a pen.LOl..

  • Maria
    Maria
    on Dec 19, 2014

    Made one with my grand-daughter, such a cute and easy Christmas project!

    q candy cane christmas star, christmas decorations, crafts, repurposing upcycling, seasonal holiday decor
  • Linda Thompson
    Linda Thompson
    on Dec 20, 2014

    I love them. What a simple way to use candy canes. I'll have to try one next year. Thanks for sharing!

  • Pam Bowers
    Pam Bowers
    on Dec 20, 2014

    That is so cute and creative.

  • Pam Bowers
    Pam Bowers
    on Dec 20, 2014

    That is so cute and creative.

  • Jayne
    Jayne
    on Dec 20, 2014

    I like both

  • Maggie C
    Maggie C
    on Dec 20, 2014

    A really cool idea. I like the 2nd one best, but I would end up eating the ornament after the holidays, as well. I would figure up how much the canes and glue cost, and then figure a cost for your time. People don't value something too cheap, but of course they don't like anything too expensive, either. We're not real easy to please. LOL @Maria, yours is cool, too. I love the way the canes made hearts.

  • Sue
    Sue
    on Dec 20, 2014

    Very cute. I like the second one better too.

  • Danee Kaplan
    Danee Kaplan
    on Dec 20, 2014

    Really a cute project. I think they both look terrific. If you need to add a stabilizer like you did here I would consider using glittered chipboard and/or a snowflake shape rather than a circle just to keep it festive. You could use a cheap plastic snowflake ornament from any store or cut a chipboard snowflake with with any of the hundreds of dies or an electronic cutter. You may have to sandwich several layers of chipboard to make it thick enough to provide support, especially if you cut it on a Silhouette or Cricut. As for hanging I would recommend monofilament aka fishing line. A bow would overpower the design entirely and only the thinest ribbon will look right. A few of these in a big window- especially with a few small ones added- would be so adorable.

  • Kathie taylor
    Kathie taylor
    on Dec 20, 2014

    When I first saw this, the WOW factor hit me! Keep them up until Valentines!!!!

  • Colleen
    Colleen
    on Dec 20, 2014

    I attempted this project and the canes would NOT stick to the cardboard for some reason. Mine wasn't as pretty as yours are either. Maybe my cardboard wasn't large enough-I don't know. I put small chipboard letters on mine for "hoho". It looked pretty, but it wouldn't hold a bow either!! Happy Holidays to all.

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Colleen I ended up using E6000 on the ones I glued to the cardboard.

  • Marlene Wilson
    Marlene Wilson
    on Dec 20, 2014

    This is a beautiful Star you have made,I like it!

  • Lorraine depaolo st.george
    Lorraine depaolo st.george
    on Dec 20, 2014

    funny but, I like the first one...I'm an artist

  • Rose Tomlinson
    Rose Tomlinson
    on Dec 21, 2014

    really cool project.

  • MaryStLouis
    MaryStLouis
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I like the top photo with the cardboard showing. The extra cane pieces spoil the simplicity of this pretty design. As for hanging ideas, I would hot glue a picture hanger to the back of the cardboard if you think it's strong enough. If not, you could hot glue a string to both sides of the cardboard to create a centered ribbon.

  • Anna Ibarra
    Anna Ibarra
    on Dec 21, 2014

    Gosh, they are both a neat idea. But I aim more for the all candy cane look.

  • Joseph Karsok
    Joseph Karsok
    on Dec 21, 2014

    First one, less complicated design. Second cluttered, loses the delicate intricacy of #1. Ribbon, depends on strength of bonding. As close to center as possible. Maybe even thin wire or nylon string instead of ribbon.

  • G B
    G B
    on Dec 21, 2014

    Like these. Tried doing this last year using the glue gun...disaster.

  • Cynthia
    Cynthia
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I like the first one~ but I LOVE hearts so both are special~ Why won't the glue stick easily? Must be anothe type that would work better for simplicity sake! Use trilene (fish line) on the cardboard to hang! Sweet gift!

  • Ellen
    Ellen
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I tend to agree with @Joseph Karsok, that the first one looks better, although I like them both. Ideas from@Danee Kaplan appeal to me also, but the red anchors the center of the design and I would not change the color. If hanging is a problem due to the weight of the candy you might want to use a picture hanger type of thing, like maybe a paper clip (?) glued to the back of the center. But you may need a more stable center or heavier cardboard to make that work. I have had some projects tip forward when I tried to attach fishing line to the center back because of weight above that point. this is a very cute item. Good luck! Sorry! Had not seen @MaryStLouis comment. Sorry for duplication!

  • Donna
    Donna
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I like them both but the simplicity of the first one is striking. Great job!

  • Pam Potter
    Pam Potter
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I Like them both----from one crafter and artist to another---I think if you could trace the middle star shape and cut your cardboard to that shape and not the circle--and have it red or white---it would make them look much more attractive---Very creative

  • Pam Potter
    Pam Potter
    on Dec 21, 2014

    A hot glue gun will keep the candies together easier---If you do the star shape in a thick cardboard---you could put a tab off a soda can and hot glue it to the back--or poke wire through and move over and inch and poke back through and twist together and make it where that is the place to hang it---or you could cut two stars---and make a ribbon loop by glueing the ribbon strip on one side of the point and glue the other side on the other side of a point---make the ribbon showing or not showing---then glue the other cardboard star to the side-----or cut some stars out of wood to the shape in the middle and attach a picture hanger bar on them---hope one of these ideas will help

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Pam Potter Thank you for the idea. I'm going to try that next year.

  • Margaret
    Margaret
    on Dec 21, 2014

    Hard as both look great. Another idea for the backing - trivets.

  • Myra
    Myra
    on Dec 21, 2014

    Use a peppermint lollypop for the center?

  • Nancy Shaw
    Nancy Shaw
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I love the first one- that being said, I made one this year and had a very hard time hanging it. It finally fell off the wall and broke into a "million pieces". Good luck!

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Nancy Shaw I never could get a hanger to work on it so I just blinged it up some more.

  • Myra
    Myra
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I may try this this with clay just for an ornament.

  • Cecelia Mavis
    Cecelia Mavis
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I like the first one. could the ribbon be attached to the back of the cardboard or in between the layers of cardboard

  • Denise D
    Denise D
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I like the first one the best but the second is pretty nice too.

  • Jac
    Jac
    on Dec 21, 2014

    I vote for #2. The complexity of the center lends itself to actual snowflake patterns. Also, having been the recipient of unwrapped peppermint crafts, I hope you finished yours with a sealant. Spray poly, perhaps?

  • Carole
    Carole
    on Dec 22, 2014

    Please send me instructions? How do you get candy to stick together ? How would you hang this without breaking? Love them both! Awesome!

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Carole I'll try to give you some instructions. I used 10 canes on the bottom and 10 on the top. make each one into 5 hearts. I ended up leaving the wrappers on and hot glued the canes together. It took me some practice to get a shape and I ended up laying the canes out how I wanted them and drew a line to go by. I did the same thing on the top only turning them the opposite way and hot glue them together and to the bottom ones. Once you lay them out you can tell where to glue them. I just hot glued the peppermints around where I thought they looked good and I had already unwrapped them so used them that way. After I was done with it,it wasn't very stable so all I could think to do,at the time,was cut the cardboard and paint it. I used 2 pieces of cardboard and hot glued them together then painted it. I used E6000 to glue the top ones to the circle so it would be more sturdy. I decided to bling it up a little with red and white fake pearl necklaces that I cut apart and hot glued on,alternating the colors. There are several other good ideas posted by others too. Thank you. You could always use E6000 on the whole thing.

  • Nancy Mangano
    Nancy Mangano
    on Dec 22, 2014

    I like them both but the second one is better and I thought using something that's not candy so it can be up all year on the wall.

  • Becky Fedler
    Becky Fedler
    on Dec 22, 2014

    Saw this in a picture where people had started a tribute to the Slain New York police officers. Soooooo Sad.

  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Dec 22, 2014

    Thank to everyone who likes it and commented on it.Means a lot to me since I'm not a crafty person but trying to learn. I tried and tried to put a ribbon on but it just wouldn't hold it. It's sturdy but not enough to hang. So I blinged it up a little and here is the final product. Hope you like it too. Just felt like I needed to do something with the red piece so i bought those red and white cheap string necklaces and used those.

    q candy cane christmas star, christmas decorations, crafts, repurposing upcycling, seasonal holiday decor
  • Pam Potter
    Pam Potter
    on Dec 22, 2014

    went to Walmart yesterday and they have light weight wooden stars in the craft section and the star points are circles--perfect for this to be made on

  • Lynn Clugston
    Lynn Clugston
    on Dec 23, 2014

    I love it and can see several other ideas you could do. Could even try making with the small candy canes, that would be lighter. A comment about glue...I have used numerous types of glues with different craft projects and I think hot glue would be the way to go.

  • Karen Wright
    Karen Wright
    on Dec 23, 2014

    I think it is perfect in EVERY way---I would think a drink tab glued with the E6000 would be the best hanger---if you use a hot glue gun---the weight of the glue stick/ornament---it could pop off----also gorilla glue would be an extra expense to glue a hanger---but it is thinner than the others and it holds everything. It does not dry clear however so it would not be good to make the ornament with. It is a good purchase tho for just abt everything just like E6000. Please post your instructions----I am impressed and sometimes not so easily!!!!!!!!

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Dec 29, 2014

      @Karen Wright . I used 10 canes on the bottom and 10 on the top. make each one into 5 hearts. I ended up leaving the wrappers on and hot glued the canes together. It took me some practice to get a shape and I ended up laying the canes out how I wanted them and drew a line to go by. I did the same thing on the top only turning them the opposite way and hot glue them together and to the bottom ones. Once you lay them out you can tell where to glue them. I just hot glued the peppermints around where I thought they looked good and I had already unwrapped them so used them that way. After I was done with it,it wasn't very stable so all I could think to do,at the time,was cut the cardboard and paint it. I used 2 pieces of cardboard and hot glued them together then painted it. I used E6000 to glue the top ones to the circle so it would be more sturdy. I decided to bling it up a little with red and white fake pearl necklaces that I cut apart and hot glued on,alternating the colors. There are several other good ideas posted by others too. Thank you. You could always use E6000 on the whole thing.

  • Sharon An Don Maloney
    Sharon An Don Maloney
    on Dec 23, 2014

    love the second one I would use hot glue an wire an attach at top hide it with a small bow that matches the ribbon wrapped around the wile to hide it

  • WannaBGardener
    WannaBGardener
    on Dec 23, 2014

    #2 is my favorite. I think a ribbon would hide your creativity, but if you must have one put a small or medium sized ribbon at the top. Please post a final picture!

  • Venus Thecla Correa Mynatt
    Venus Thecla Correa Mynatt
    on Dec 23, 2014

    I thinks it's simply adorable! What a creative star you made. That would be a beautiful star for a Christmas tree or to hang on the door!

  • Lelap
    Lelap
    on Dec 23, 2014

    Whichever design you choose--I really like your bllinged up version--this is adorable! Success for a beginning crafter, for sure. I have seen packages of artificial candy canes that might be lighter and stayed glued together better.

    q candy cane christmas star, christmas decorations, crafts, repurposing upcycling, seasonal holiday decor, These were in the Dollar Tree catalog 6 in a package
  • Ruidoso
    Ruidoso
    on Dec 23, 2014

    All three are beautiful and for a beginning crafter--FANTASTIC! Use the 1/4 or 1/8 inch red ribbon fastened with hot glue. I would NOT hang it on a door unless you put it on a door that stays open or closed most of the time. It's too fragile. See, you ARE creative!

  • Dawn Theisen
    Dawn Theisen
    on Dec 23, 2014

    I love it!

  • Patty Painter
    Patty Painter
    on Dec 23, 2014

    Love the blinged up version too. Also you could paint the center white instead of red and glue some lace on it. Like a doily.

  • Suzette Briggs
    Suzette Briggs
    on Dec 23, 2014

    I really love # 1 it looks cleaner, but 2 is also cute.

  • Kathie taylor
    Kathie taylor
    on Dec 23, 2014

    Note to Florida people making this, don't use hot glue because of our 80* + weather. !Dollar Tree had the plastic ones at the beginning of this year.

  • Kgirl
    Kgirl
    on Dec 24, 2014

    Pretty cool!

  • Nancy Mangano
    Nancy Mangano
    on Dec 25, 2014

    I would use fake candy so you have no bugs, it would look good as a clock..

  • Bessie Ashby
    Bessie Ashby
    on Dec 25, 2014

    I made one. similar to this. I used hot glue to put 9 hearts together then I put a sparkley snowflake in the center and some small round plastic flat sided red jewls at the points of a few of the harts and one in the center of the snow flake.then I turned it over and hot glued some little round magnets on the back side of 3 of the little red jewels so I could put it on the refrig. I think it is beautiful.

  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Dec 29, 2014

    Here's how I finished it. i bought 2 cheap fake red and white pearl necklaces and cut them..Then glued them around the star,alternating the colors.. i never could get a hanger on it. what do you think? I'll make some more next year and change it up so a ribbon can be used for a hanger. Thanks everyone.

    q candy cane christmas star, christmas decorations, crafts, repurposing upcycling, seasonal holiday decor
    • Pam Potter
      Pam Potter
      on Dec 31, 2014

      @Kletta That is nice too---now if you want to keep the price down and stay with the candy theme---change the beads to per say---red hots cinnamon candy and white Tic Tacks for the white---or any red and white hard candy

  • Amy Petracek
    Amy Petracek
    on Dec 29, 2014

    I love this, if you just hang on the wall I think it should be ok, as a wreath on the door I think it would break the first time someone shuts the door. It is very pretty.

  • Trace
    Trace
    on Dec 29, 2014

    beautiful and creative.

  • Nancy G
    Nancy G
    on Dec 30, 2014

    so adorable!

  • Valerie Jean
    Valerie Jean
    on Dec 30, 2014

    Looks very nice!=== candy canes in all colors are on sale now @ Walmart, you gave me an idea I think I'll get the yellow ones, and the blue ones for wreaths that I can hang year 'round!

  • Katrina Warren
    Katrina Warren
    on Dec 30, 2014

    @Kletta I absolutely Love This! I'll be giving it a try using plastic candy canes! Thanks for sharing!

  • Dorothy
    Dorothy
    on Dec 31, 2014

    Love this idea. So new

  • Linn
    Linn
    on Dec 31, 2014

    That is so clever! I really like the use of the peppermint candy instead of the pom poms. The cut candy cane in the center is pure genius! Thanks for sharing.

  • Lori Brinkworth
    Lori Brinkworth
    on Dec 31, 2014

    pretty but I think breakable, but then you eat them LOL

  • Lottie_davenport @aol.com
    Lottie_davenport @aol.com
    on Dec 31, 2014

    cute idea,but too much work, to break so easy

  • Sherry Fram
    Sherry Fram
    on Dec 31, 2014

    Wow that's a lot of work and very pretty! Like the second one best! I would attach a wide ribbon to the cardboard and to the canes it would be behind to hang it. I think it might give it a little more stability.

  • Ruth Standish
    Ruth Standish
    on Jan 1, 2015

    I like both of them but the first one is my favorite.

  • Susan
    Susan
    on Jan 1, 2015

    I love the one with the beads ... they give the wreath a very finished and professional look. Thanks for the great idea!

    • Ruth Standish
      Ruth Standish
      on Jan 1, 2015

      @Susan I have looked at both pictures and I don't see any beads, just candy canes and peppermint discs.

  • Mary Ross
    Mary Ross
    on Jan 1, 2015

    Love the one with the beads.....try painting the red discs silver. Celestial comes to mind.

  • Georgeanne I
    Georgeanne I
    on Jan 1, 2015

    That's lovely and creative. What's the problem?

  • Sherry Valentine
    Sherry Valentine
    on Jan 1, 2015

    Love it!!! --- Very Creative!!!

  • Toooo cute!

  • Sherry
    Sherry
    on Jan 1, 2015

    I love both of them! You did a great job! :-)

  • Lori
    Lori
    on Jan 1, 2015

    love this idea, always love something unique

  • Deborah Seamon
    Deborah Seamon
    on Jan 1, 2015

    I do these every year and everyone looks forward to getting one now

  • Valerie Jean
    Valerie Jean
    on Jan 2, 2015

    Looks very nice, thanks for the helpful hints, I gathered all my supplies, and the season flew by, and NO wreath! Maybe next year. HNY to everyone!

  • Hazel mckinney
    Hazel mckinney
    on Jan 25, 2015

    I absolutely love this!! May I have your permission to copycat your wreath.

  • Lori
    Lori
    on Aug 15, 2015

    I like the extra candy pieces.

  • Donna Makowski
    Donna Makowski
    on Aug 15, 2015

    Extra candy pieces!!

  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Aug 16, 2015

    Thank you ladies..

  • Hazel mckinney
    Hazel mckinney
    on Aug 19, 2015

    I love this and I am actually going to make this . So unique.

  • Diane F
    Diane F
    on Aug 19, 2015

    This is so unique! I prefer it without the extra pieces. Instead of using cardboard, would a plastic lid also work?

    • Kletta
      Kletta
      on Sep 27, 2015

      @Diane F Yes I'm sure it would. Anything to make it sturdy would probably work.

  • Kathleen
    Kathleen
    on Aug 26, 2015

    Wonderful either way - my grandchildren would me nuts for this so I think I will wait till they are a bit older to try it but it is just wonderful.

  • Scarlet
    Scarlet
    on Nov 8, 2015

    I would add a big red bow on to the center. Hot glue it to the extra candy (or a cardboard circle)

  • Carrie Hawk
    Carrie Hawk
    on Nov 11, 2015

    So cute.

  • Carrie Hawk
    Carrie Hawk
    on Nov 11, 2015

    Could glue a old CD to back for stability. Sparkle might be fun.

  • Kerensa Zieske
    Kerensa Zieske
    on Nov 11, 2015

    one might add themed scrap book paper to the CD if you don't prefer sparkle (I like the sparkle idea though)

  • Lori
    Lori
    on Nov 14, 2015

    This is beautiful! I agree that sparkle could be fun--a sugary sparkle. Love the graphic nature of this piece-- so tradional yet modern.

  • Judith DAVIS
    Judith DAVIS
    on Nov 14, 2015

    I liked the bottom one with the small pieces in the middle, gives it more ump!! If you know what I mean. Very nice idea

  • Margaret
    Margaret
    on Nov 15, 2015

    I think it is a fantastic idea and it looks great.

  • Chris Teague
    Chris Teague
    on Dec 12, 2015

    Love this! Without the extra pieces though, makes it to busy!

  • Jean Myles
    Jean Myles
    on Dec 14, 2015

    Awesome! I like the one without the extra pieces and I think the CD idea sounds great. Not a fan of seeing the red disc on behind.

  • Barbars
    Barbars
    on Aug 22, 2016

    Beautiful

  • Debra Rainer Arthur
    Debra Rainer Arthur
    on Nov 7, 2016

    I love both!!

  • Eva
    Eva
    on Nov 29, 2016

    I like the first pic best. it's less cluttered. I would jazz up the red backing with glitter trim in a frosty white color to make it pop... hand the hanger from it as well.
  • Allorrah Be
    Allorrah Be
    on Dec 24, 2016

    It's a beautiful piece of work!! I would love to see it stuck in place with Command hangers or something "invisible" but a pretty red ribbon would be nice, too. I love it best without the extra pieces in the center; I'd put sparkles on the center piece. Maybe I'll try one next year!
    • Maureen dudley
      Maureen dudley
      on Dec 28, 2016

      Love the top one, the red circle underneath stands it out. I would even think about green background, drop for the underneath of it, or sparkly (pearly) white.
  • Linda Thompson
    Linda Thompson
    on Dec 29, 2016

    I like the top one. I made one of these for my friend this year for the holidays. She loved it. I should have put s red ribbon or bow on it. If I make another one, I probably will.
  • None
    None
    on Dec 29, 2016

    I' craving candy canes now
  • Kletta
    Kletta
    on Dec 30, 2016

    Thank you everyone. I'm surprised it's still being found on here to be commented on. ☺
  • Laura
    Laura
    on Jan 11, 2017

    I used my oven to "glue" pieces together. Line a cookie or sheet pan with parchment paper and lay out your design. Place in pre-heated 350 degree oven. Leave only a few minutes for the candy to become tacky. Take out and shape. I love the peppermint bowls. Using parchment paper, lay candies touching and move out from the center to the size bowl you want. When tacky, remove from oven and drape over glass or bowl and let dry.
  • Susan
    Susan
    on Dec 10, 2017

    Beautiful

  • Donna Fields
    Donna Fields
    on Dec 16, 2018

    107

  • Beth McGarey
    Beth McGarey
    on Dec 22, 2018

    They are adorable. We use to use hot glue on the candy cane wreaths we make but we may have to try the E6000 glue. We found that a CD on the back of the candy canes is another good way to help stabilize the wreath. You can either spray paint them silver or what ever color the candy canes are. One with no label also works!! Happy crafting!!

Your comment...