I need suggestions for deer proof plants .

Margaret
by Margaret
The plants should be tall and thrive in a mostly shady area with minimum water.

  5 answers
  • Linda Sikut Linda Sikut on Jun 26, 2017

    I just did a search using these words. ' hardiness zone oregon, deer proof, shade, little water, tall plants '


    Google turned up a lot of plants for each part of the search terms. I'm not sure if any of these meet all of your criteria or only one or two. Hopefully when you click on the picture, then on Visit Page, you'll find some answers.


    HTH

  • 13526476 13526476 on Jun 26, 2017

    Refer to Green Gardening with Ann Lovejoy of Log House Plants, regarding "Deer Resistant Plants." Sadly, when it comes to real living plants, “deer proof” is not a realizable goal. The best we can hope for is to come up with a list of generally deer resistant plants. What that usually boils down to is

    1) a roster of plants that are outright toxic (castor beans, foxglove);

    2) plants that deer don’t like well enough to eat all of (ivy, lavender), and

    3) plants that grow faster than the deer can eat them (bamboo, grasses).

    Bane or Beauty?

    Voracious and charming, greedy and beautiful, deer can be the bane or the grace of the garden. Although young deer will eat pretty much anything, mature deer are more discriminating. Sort of. Though there really is no such thing as a deer-proof plant, there definitely are deer resistant ones. Often these are plants with hairy, smelly, waxy, dense, or highly textured foliage.

    Over the years, I’ve seen many lists from all over the county citing plants deer love and plants deer hate. Amazingly, some of the same plants appear on each list. Evidently deer in one region happily eat things that deer elsewhere don’t.



    • Margaret Margaret on Jun 26, 2017

      Yes, our deer vary from year to year as to what they will eat. Last year was the first time in ten years that they ate dahlias. Two years ago they ate all our rhubarb. I know they love hostas, snapdragons, petunias, roses...I planted zinnias last year and they left them alone as well as the daisies. Thanks for your help


  • Janet Pizaro Janet Pizaro on Jun 26, 2017

    What is your location?

    • Margaret Margaret on Jun 26, 2017

      I live in Roseburg OR (southwestern) between the Cascade Mt range and the Coastal Mt range. Winters are mild by NY standards.

  • Bink Bink on Jun 26, 2017

    Try planting Red Twig and other plants that deer like to feed on, far away from your garden. It looks pretty and steers them away from your garden. PLEASE don't use toxic plants!! So cruel. Deer are a critical part of our growth in socially chosen areas.

    • Margaret Margaret on Jun 26, 2017

      I may try that. We live way out in the country so there is lots of forage for them, but toward the end of the summer when everything gets dry they head for anything that has been watered and is green. I now plant tomatoes on our deck and fence it off every night.

  • Cori Widen Cori Widen on Jun 26, 2017

    You can also try sprinkling Irish Spring soap shavings, a lot of people on Hometalk report that it helps a ton!