One room just doesn’t cool like the rest of the house

Maegirl
by Maegirl

One room doesn't cool like the rest of the house. Running two fans (cieling and standalone) and on hot days this room is hard to sleep in because it gets soo hot.

Few details:

*A/C is less than 3 years old

*Room is smallest (10.5x11 - 9ft high celing)

*told it is closest room to attic furnace

*other side of one wall is the garage

*told A/C system is appropriate for size of house

*Registers are all the way open (until recently-see below)

*A/C filter changed regularly

*6" duct in this room (primary bedroom has 8")


Builder's HVAC contractor visited and believes the solutions are:

1. close the registers 1/2 way in 3 other rooms to increase flow in the problem room (most likely there will be temp issues in more places if I leave that way - primary bedroom, dining nook & kitchen)

2. keep problem bedroom's door cracked open at all times (most people shut their bedroom door)

3. Only use the cheapest A/C air filters and change monthly. Use these vs the upgraded ones I've installed to help catch dust, etc, as the better ones will "restrict intake too much and will hurt motor" (nevermind allergies and other airborne concerns). Note that initially, their cheaper filter was installed and the problem in the bedroom existed then as well.


To add to this, they discovered the furnace in the attic had a lot of drainage (leak?) and said they fixed the issue. I asked them to take pic, see attached:

1. They taped area (black tape in pic)

2. They removed and left cap off (cap was were the treads show in same picture). Said they recently discovered the unit drains better without cap.


Note that I am not the only homeowner in my home development that has the temp issue in same room.


Are there any who have worked with or experienced this type of issue that can share their knowledge and suggestions? Your replies will be very much appreciated.


Thank you

They taped and took off cap

A/C Filter recommended

  8 answers
  • I would get a second opinion. If several of you are having the same problem, you should work together to insist the issue be corrected by the builder.

    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 03, 2021

      I agree, another neighbor and I are pushing them to resolve. I can't accept and their suggestions so I am conducting a little research. Thanks for reply.

  • Kathy Gunter Law Kathy Gunter Law on Nov 03, 2021

    Insulation is the only other thing that I can think of that you might upgrade.

    On another note, regarding the filters, the HVAC person who replaced my unit at our home as well as the one (different company) who installed the unit at our farm said you should use the less dense filters and change monthly. Ace Hardware, store brand, gets my recommendation.

    • See 1 previous
    • Kathy Gunter Law Kathy Gunter Law on Nov 03, 2021

      Yes, I agree. My home filters aren't bad but the one at the farm is horrible even at 1 month. I use the 3 month Ace filter and replace monthly because a dirty filter really puts a strain on the unit. This is a great place to hear how others have suffered through and made some very interesting discoveries and solutions.


    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 03, 2021

      Both sites have great information. I am currently looking into having another HVAC company to check it out, if builder doesn't respond. I hate to have to pay for something I basically already paid for plus, as mention on one of the sites you provided, there could be other issues that are the real cause of the problem. Thanks for your reply and information.

  • William William on Nov 03, 2021

    First photo is just the drain for the condensation from the AC coil. Don't know why a cap was put on it. Wall insulation on the garage side would help. I would use foam board insulation. Spray foam for any cracks, spaces, or openings. Check to make sure the return vent in the room is not blocked and grill is clean. Every room, except bathrooms, have supply and return registers. Since the main unit is in the attic check to make sure the supply and return duct are connected, not crushed, and any connections are taped with foil tape. You may need to have the 6" duct changed to an 8" or add another 6" duct.

    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 03, 2021

      I see that I may have to hire another company to check out things as I agree with your advice. Any part of the system I can reach has been checked and rechecked and is good.


      There are treads for a screw on cap for the drain system, shown in the pic. Do you know why it is there if a cap is not recommended?


      I also wonder if taping the drain was right or was it something they should have just replaced? I wouldn't have known about it if I hadn't listened to them talking in the attic and asked questions and for a picture. I mean if it was DIY I wouldn't question using fix it tape but it was done by the actual company who installed the system.


      Thanks for your reply. Great to have people to run these things by for feedback.

  • 17335038 17335038 on Nov 03, 2021

    Is your garage insulated in the walls/ceiling?

    Is it cooled by A/C during hot weather?

    How hot does the garage get compared with the small room in question?

    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 03, 2021

      Not sure about garage insulation. The house is cooled by A/C. The problem pertains to the one bedroom which shares a wall with the garage and this room remains hotter than the other rooms in the house.

  • William William on Nov 03, 2021

    Some HVAC companies do things differently. I assume the cap was put to prevent overflow in case the drain line got plugged since the unit is in the attic but it isn't needed and does restrict the flow of the condensate from draining. I have never done that. Yes, taping around the drain lines is correct. Any little opening or gap will suck air in from where the unit is located when it's running. Attics get really hot in the summer and hot air mixing with cold air will cause the unit run longer since the house won't cool down enough to shut down. And vice versa in the winter. Is the air flow in the room from the register as strong as some of the other rooms? Did you check to make sure the return grill is clear and not blocked so air can return to the unit?

    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 03, 2021

      Hello, Good to know about taping and I wonder if there was more of a problem than we knew.


      Initially my A/C was found to have too much refrigerant a little over 2 years ago and once fixed, we utilized A/C all this time without issue except that we have always had the one room with strange temp. Except for one other bedroom, all bedroom doors are closed at night but only this one room stays hotter at night when hot days or colder when cold outside.


      The techs supposedly checked the grill/register and confirmed it was fully open, that my air filter wasn't caked with dust (I change it regularly), said they confirmed that the duct wasn't kinked or leaking. Using a special machine they were able to tell that the airflow was unusually low but it got a little better after they closed 3 other registers, in other rooms, half way and more so after they removed the air filter completely. I expect these closures will now cause issues in other rooms but will see.


      I inquired and they said the 6" duct is appropriate for the room size. I asked if system was proper size for home and they said yes. I asked if the room was the end of the line and was told that it was the closest room to furnace so that shouldn't be an issue but now that I think about it, I wonder exactly how the duct is structured.


      Thanks for reply, I see I really need to have someone other than the company who installed come out to review system and investigate overall issue. Appreciate the replies.

  • William William on Nov 03, 2021

    You do have a point on how the duct to the room is structured. It may be the closest to the unit but if the duct to it is too long off the main trunk, or has bends or elbows, those are restrictions. Every elbow or bend is basically equal to 10' of straight run. If they had to close three registers half way to get the air flow better then there is a problem with the duct to that room. I agree in getting another company to check the system out. They may provide a solution. A long run can be shortened if possible. A straighter direct run using 45 degree elbows in place of 90 degree elbows, if that is a problem, would be less restriction. If the duct to the room is flexible corrugated foil faced replacing with rigid sheet metal pipe could solve the problem. If the duct is flexible corrugated any drop along it's span can cause a restriction. Final recourse would be to add another 6" duct run and supply register in the room. Return should be sufficient.

  • Since the room is next to the garage and neighbors are having the same issue with the same room configuration, you might try insulating that shared wall. Stands to reason if that particular room is warmer than the others, the garage isn't insulated. I'd personally try that first before getting more involved with the HVAC system.

    • Maegirl Maegirl on Nov 06, 2021

      I agree, insulation may be the problem. Our main issue is that the builder needs to be the one who pays to make things right versus the home owners and we may need confirmation from a company other than the ones who caused the problem. However, I am still holding off a bit to give the builder time to respond. Thank you for response.