Old Thread

Recently I also inherited a lot of old thread (I love the wooden spools) but I have heard that old thread isn't as strong as it deteriorates. I'm wondering if this is a concern If I plan on using this thread in some quilts I have promised to complete for my grandmother who passed away a year ago. Attached is a picture of only about half of the thread I have inherited, not including the thread I have been collecting myself.
On the left are mostly empty but have those awesome wooden spools.
Empty wooden thread spools on the left new and old thread on the right...
  33 answers
  • Twila Palmatier Twila Palmatier on Nov 08, 2013
    DO NOT USE IT AND ESPECIALLY ON QUILTS - BE THEY OLD OR NEW!
  • Valerie Valerie on Nov 09, 2013
    I would agree with Twila - making quilts is both time-consuming and expensive, and it would be a shame if they did not 'last' because of the choice of thread.
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 09, 2013
      @Valerie I agree I want the quilt tops my grandmother made (at age 95) to last my aunts and uncles through theirs and their children's lifetimes intact!
  • Julie Moyna Julie Moyna on Nov 09, 2013
    Since you shouldn't use it, make Christmas crafts with them...I am sure Pinterest has ideas :)
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 09, 2013
      @Julie Moyna thats a great idea something people wouldn't use a lot and if they kept it wouldnt' be going on and off a sleeping child!
  • Jeanette S Jeanette S on Nov 09, 2013
    How old is old? Have you tried testing it? How was it stored? I would not just assume it is not good, but would wind off several yards and test it every so few inches to see if it broke easily!
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 09, 2013
      @Jeanette S thank you for your reply, I am glad that that I have someone who agrees if I try it and it seems strong that it would be ok to use. I would think some of this thread is not old at all...my grandmother sewed right up to 2 weeks before she passed away last year!
  • Patti Patti on Nov 09, 2013
    I agree with Jeanette. Test before you don't use it. Some older thread survives just fine. I have 30 year old silk thread from my mother-in-law that I still use. Sew (quilt) a swatch to see how the thread holds up. You will know quickly if you should use it or not. Good luck, please post pictures of the quilts that you've finished. I'm sure all of us would enjoy seeing them.
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 09, 2013
      @Patti I was thinking there were some thread that could possibly last a lot longer than the cheaper stuff. I was actually thinking if it was polyester it would never degrade (haha) especially in the landfillls.... but some of these are gold, silver, etc and though I will not use on quilts I plan on using them somehow!
  • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 09, 2013
    Thank you all for your input. Some of the thread is not very old, I was thinking more of some of the serger sewing thread when my mom doesn't even have a serger it worked on, and when I see the wooden spools I am a little suspect, but I was thinking exactly what @Patti and @Jeanette S said if I use some of it and it seem safe if it would be ok to use....I like how it looks (the wooden spools and the taller serger thread) so would probably use it as a decoration, but was concerned about using the old thread in something I wanted to last!
  • Valerie Valerie on Nov 09, 2013
    I think that Jeanette and others have a valid point. I also did not realise that your grandmother had passed away so recently, so I am also going to change my opinion. So long as you are comfortable that the thread is strong enough - I say go for it!
  • Francine Mosuk-Regnier Francine Mosuk-Regnier on Nov 10, 2013
    It depends on the type of thread it is. Cotton thread will disintegrate over time; however if you have polyester thread, which is an oil byproduct, it will last forever.
  • Karen B Karen B on Nov 10, 2013
    The wooden spools can be painted to look like little drums to make cute Christmas ornaments.
  • Cyndi Neumann Cyndi Neumann on Nov 10, 2013
    You can do lots of crafting with thread spools, Have you seen the new Mary Jane Farm Magazine? It has a couple of articles on them. Smiles, Cyndi
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 10, 2013
      @Cyndi Neumann thank you for the ideas I've been looking at those...Someday I think I'd like to have all handmade ornaments on my tree, since I don't have kids guess I'll have to do them myself!
  • Lynne Sedgewick Lyon Lynne Sedgewick Lyon on Nov 10, 2013
    I have an old spool labeled black cotton coat thread. It's at least 50 years old, coming from my grandma's house. It's still great and I save it to use for the jobs that need strength like sewing on coat buttons etc. Definitely do some strength testing before discarding. And I love the wooden spools! Crafty Fun can be had with them!
  • Jeanette freeze Jeanette freeze on Nov 10, 2013
    lots nice wood spool for sure but iam with all remarked new thread is best use for bottoms crafts,
  • Elaine Elaine on Nov 10, 2013
    I have lots of this thread for sale if anyone is interested
  • Kathryn Kibat Kathryn Kibat on Nov 10, 2013
    all you can do is test the strength.
  • Tammy McLain Tammy McLain on Nov 10, 2013
    I have the same issue,, inherited some old thread on wooden spools. Thanks for sharing!
  • Mssmatch Mssmatch on Nov 10, 2013
    as a quilter I would only use new quilting thread. For other projects it should be fine. I have noticed over time certain threads do lose strength. You put a lot of time in making a quilt so it only makes sense to start with new thread.
  • Shirley Heim Davis Shirley Heim Davis on Nov 10, 2013
    I have often put old thread in a ziptop baggie and placed it in the freezer for storage. This allows the thread to absorb moisture and replace at least some of its lost strength. I probably would not usefor my quilts except as a basting thread. Even after spending time in the freezer, I don't feel it is trustworthy enough for my quilts.
  • Patt Popple Patt Popple on Nov 10, 2013
    old cotton thread should be unwound a few times and discarded, its been exposed to air and light etc, which I've found weakens it. Testing the rest is the way to go. I have lots of it, and they are waiting for me to craft with them, they're beautiful as they are...
  • Evelyn McMullen Evelyn McMullen on Nov 10, 2013
    Lucky you! I've heard, but haven't tried this, put old thread in the freezer for a time to revitalize it. Can't hurt to try it. Good luck.
    • See 1 previous
    • Patt Popple Patt Popple on Nov 11, 2013
      @Evelyn McMullen wow, that's a great idea. I volunteer at a recycle/repurpose facility where I organize all the fabric etc. donations...I'll have to share these hints!
  • Jody Jody on Nov 10, 2013
    You have a treasure. The wooden spools make great necklaces if you have girls in the family they can wear aa cute decorated spool for a lost treasure. Check out pinterest for deco ideas. Im so looking for them I need some.
  • Love Digging in the Dirt Love Digging in the Dirt on Nov 10, 2013
    I too have many old wooden spools of thread and in my use of them, the thread breaks very easily. If you are going to do a project that involves all the effort and time, I would use new thread.
  • Debbi W Debbi W on Nov 10, 2013
    Same here Debra Todd I took have found the old thread to break easy, I second our advice to NOT use it on a project, but I can be used in a sewing room in so many ways as decor.
  • Jean DeSavage Jean DeSavage on Nov 10, 2013
    Make lace with it! If you use netting in between two layers of Solvy water soluble stabilizer, you can sew all kinds of shapes and designs, being sure to have the threads cross over each other. You can do it without the netting, but you would have to definitely do a thread stitched base netting of stitches, and then do your designs. You can also add fabric scraps and cool yarns and specialty threads. I would use the old spools as they are and make garlands for a Christmas tree, if you don't use the threads for lace. I remember seeing spool dolls when I was a kid.
  • Cynthia H Cynthia H on Nov 10, 2013
    I have my old spools displayed in containers. So pretty, but the thread is weak as others have mentioned. If you really want to use it, try some of the hints mentioned.
  • Patt Popple Patt Popple on Nov 10, 2013
    I have a Pinterest board titled "wooden spools" . Lots of ideas!
  • Elaine Elaine on Nov 10, 2013
    Hi, Please email me at e herrington4 @ cogeco.ca. I live in Ontario, Canada. And would like to sell
  • Shirley Heim Davis Shirley Heim Davis on Nov 10, 2013
    I got the idea from a fellow quilter. I have done it for years now with the old thread, especially the stuff still on wooden spools - which I also love.
  • Sarah Sarah on Nov 10, 2013
    I recently bought a ring on Etsy fashioned out of a spool of thread. Very nifty.
    • Patt Popple Patt Popple on Nov 11, 2013
      @Sarah could you post the name of the Etsy board you bought the ring from?
  • Janet Arntz Janet Arntz on Nov 11, 2013
    put beeswax on it
  • Mayesathome Mayesathome on Nov 11, 2013
    The old thread tends to break a lot
  • Shirley Heim Davis Shirley Heim Davis on Nov 11, 2013
    Sorry my idea did not show up above. It is to put the thread in a ziptop baggie in the freezer for at least 24 hours, or as long as you want to. this allows the thread to absorb moisture and become a little bit stronger than it was. Jut let it come to room temperature before you use it. I would not use it in a quilting project except as basting thread, though. It still won't be strong enough.
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 11, 2013
      @Shirley Heim Davis your reply is still there just have to "click" on previous comments..but good advice even if given again.
  • Carol Carol on Nov 13, 2013
    One reason for the breakage....today's threads are made with polyester which gives them strength. The old threads, while beautiful, don't have this updated content.
    • Tanya Peterson Felsheim Tanya Peterson Felsheim on Nov 13, 2013
      @Carol Yes that was my concern about the older thread it just seems a waste to not use it, but I've gotten some great ideas here and ways to test the thread which really has helped in addition to the information you are also offering. thank you
  • Linda Kerr Linda Kerr on Nov 15, 2013
    Yes our fabrics today have polyester or other fibers in them that just cut right thru what ever you sew with them. The only answer would be to use only on 100% cotton fabric.