Stain & Paint Compatibility Question

Shari
by Shari
Is solid exterior wood stain and exterior latex paint compatible to use together?We own a horse farm/boarding facility and English riding/jumping lessons is one of the services we offer. We recently ordered EIGHT new jumps (constructed out of pressure treated wood) for our riding arena.
Once the wood dries out, we need to paint the jumps. Since the jumps will be constantly exposed to the hot Florida sun and rain 365 days a year, we want to weather-proof the wood as much as possible, not only to make the jumps last, but also to minimize the tedious and time-consuming job of frequent repainting. The base color of the jumps will be white but there will also be one or two other accent colors on each jump. Below are some photo examples of ways simple, basic jumps can be painted.
Horse jumps made from pressure treated wood
Oil based primer (to seal the wood tannins) and latex exterior paint ( for the white sections and accent colors) was recommended. However, since exterior wood stain penetrates and protects wood from the elements better than paint (and doesn't chip and peel like paint), I'm wondering if we could use a solid (white) exterior wood stain INSTEAD OF the primer and white paint....... and then paint the accent colors using exterior latex paint OVER THE SOLID WHITE STAIN.


I'm thinking if we could get a good, solid, weather-proofing foundation (like with solid white stain) over the entire surface of each jump, we could not only skip the priming step, but then we might also only have to periodically repaint the accent colors. Refreshing just the accent colors every few years seems like it would be easier than repainting 8 complete jumps.


I asked the (*paint professional*) manager at one local Sherwin Williams store about the advisability of using white exterior solid wood stain instead of the primer and white paint and he wasn't sure. With 30 acres and 22 horses on the property, we already almost have more work than we can handle so anything to minimize maintenance and upkeep is always helpful.


I definitely don't want to create more work for ourselves than necessary by doing something that isn't going to work from the get-go, or won't hold up.


Does anybody with paint experience know if we could use solid white exterior stain and expect the latex exterior paint to stick to it, long-term? Do you have any additional thoughts? Suggestions? Advice?"
Frequently asked questions
Have a question about this project?
Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 13 comments
  • Shari Shari on Apr 17, 2015
    It would appear HomeTalk administrators have changed my original post from a "Post" to a "Question." In doing so, they have deleted important details I originally included about my paint vs. stain dilemma. Now this post makes absolutely no sense! Thanks a lot HomeTalk! Now no one has a frickin' clue what I'm really trying to ask! This post now makes it look like I am just showing horse jumps. (Like anyone on HT really cares about seeing horse jumps!) Sheeeesh. My deepest apologies to fellow HT members. I'm not really an idiot who would just post pictures of horse jumps here but the HT administrators sure made me look like I am.
    • Eleanor G Eleanor G on Apr 17, 2015
      @Shari I hope it works for you as well as it did for me. As for the pics of the horsejumps, I enjoyed looking at them! I love this kind of stuff!
  • Hannah V Hannah V on Apr 17, 2015
    Hi Shari! So sorry about your inconvenience- I sent you an email from hannah@hometalk.com to try and help.
Next