Counter dilemma...

Leann Stuart
by Leann Stuart
I added a passthrough and bar area to my kitchen...I've stained the boards with a black satin stain but now that I see the counter and the new bar/pass through area together I feel like they don't go together...should I get wood counters and stain the same? Or does the current Formica counter match?
  9 answers
  • Beverly Cady Cabaday Beverly Cady Cabaday on May 08, 2015
    Looks good to me!
  • CK CK on May 08, 2015
    Looks good to me too.
  • Becky Jean Kallenberger Becky Jean Kallenberger on May 09, 2015
    It doesn't look bad with it but if you decide to find a counter top that matches the black better I wouldn't recommend wood. If money is an issue then I would stick with what you have as it looks just fine.
  • Marion Nesbitt Marion Nesbitt on May 09, 2015
    If you can make it happen somehow within your budget, I would get matching Formica while you're still in the construction phase. The colour and texture is too different. This is one of those things that can bug you so you're never really happy with it, and wished you'd done it differently in the first place. Either that or do a faux finish that matches your countertop.
  • Pam Elkins Pam Elkins on May 09, 2015
    They don't need to match. I like the contrast. I agree that wood isn't a great surface for your whole kitchen. It would require a lot of upkeep.
  • Reggie Reggie on May 09, 2015
    Once you get the room finished and accessorized, I don't think you will mind the difference. I am not a fan of everything matching.
  • Liz.breier Liz.breier on May 09, 2015
    I have noticed that they are selling backslashes that are workable for apartment rentals. Some are beautiful, and they don't cost a fortune.
  • Kelly MacGregor Kelly MacGregor on May 09, 2015
    The wood is so stinkin' gorgeous! With respect to Marion Nesbitt - don't change that - it would be tragic!! But, she's right in that if it's bugging you now, it will probably bug you later, too. I think what you have does look fine but sometimes photos can be deceiving. And if you put wood on all your hardest working countertops it sometimes isn't the most practical choice. How much is cost a factor? Maybe check out some other (solid surface?) countertop options and choose something that is in complete contrast to the black stain - then any contrast it looks purposeful - like you're trying to go in a totally different direction. Good luck! Beautiful job so far!
  • Julie Munson Julie Munson on May 10, 2015
    I would paint the wall a little darker, then the two different counter colors wouldn't stand out as much