Asked on May 04, 2016

How can I modernize this little drop leaf table?

by Laine
This is the size of an end table with a built in silverware storage, the tag inside reads" 1881 Rogers by Oneida Ltd on the tables of the Hollywood Stars" which I'm sure is the silverware , also has the brass feet like a Duncan Phyfe. Any suggestions on making it a bit more modern?
  10 answers
  • Suzanne Suzanne on May 04, 2016
    Love Duncan Phyfe furniture!! This is quite a find, and I'd have a hard time refinishing it......but a grey chalk paint with some silvery touches would be super pretty....and would be a reflection of the silverware inside!!
    • Laine Laine on May 04, 2016
      Thank You Suzanne is it a Duncan Phyfe or do other furniture makers do a similar style as well
  • Janet Pizaro Janet Pizaro on May 04, 2016
    Personally I would not paint that piece. It is very rare to see that style and to me you will be taking away from it.
  • MN Mom MN Mom on May 04, 2016
    Please don't paint this! If anything clean it up and give it s fresh stain. If it were a more popular style table that is common I would say go for it but this piece is pretty unique.
  • Tammy Sea Tammy Sea on May 04, 2016
    From the quick research that I did, this table seems to be a fairly rare antique. So rare, in fact, that the experts on Antique Road Show couldn't put a value to it because they'd never seen one. Personally, I would have a difficult time modifying this piece at all. I'd clean it up, oil it, clean the hardware, and leave it as is.
    • Laine Laine on May 04, 2016
      I had been thinking of taking the silverware dividers and such out of the box and reclining it. Had thought of giving it to our daughter for remotes/magazines etc. Now not sure what to do.😳
  • Connie Connie on May 04, 2016
    If it is indeed rare then a refinish would take away from the monetary value. A restoration however would be a different story. We have a friend who is a cabinet maker by trade but has worked on restorations at the White House and often works with Sothebys etc. he told us that refinishing a valuable antique is not the way to go. Maybe try getting hold of a reputable cabinet maker/ furniture restorer and talk to them before making any decision. It is a very pretty piece you've got there.
  • Connie Connie on May 04, 2016
    P.S. If it is a rare antique even relining would detract from the value.
  • If you have someone close to you who can appraise it then you will KNOW if it is a rare antique or a re-make. From there, you can do as you please. :)
  • Lois Lois on Jan 13, 2023

    I have the exact one, I want to know if anyone knows a good place to sale it I have children and I do not want nothing to happen to this table Duncan 5 is one of my favorite and I would hate for this table to go and get ruined.. I would love for it to go to somebody that really truly appreciate it and maybe put it where it can be cherished and adored. So if anybody can help I appreciate it thank you.

  • Redcatcec Redcatcec on Jan 14, 2023

    I agree, I would not paint this table, it is gorgeous, maybe a good cleaning, doing anything more to is would lessen the value and detract.

  • I like it the way it is!