Stain the garage or keep it painted?

We live in a community where we have a few houses with stained garage doors and they look lovely. What's your thoughts on keeping this painted or staining it?
q stain garage door ideas, curb appeal, garage doors, garages, painting
  41 answers
  • Z Z on Sep 24, 2014
    I think it looks very nice as is, but I do love a stained garage door. If you like it, go for it.

  • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 24, 2014
    I do too. I was thinking about staining it and putting some handles on it and adding those beam like deals right above it. I'm a picture person, I'd have to see it to visualize it.

    • See 5 previous
    • Z Z on Sep 26, 2014
      @Thank you Amber. I never thought about checking into essential oils. One of my nephew's wife is into that. I'm sure she'll know what could help me. Thanks for the idea.

  • Hannah V Hannah V on Sep 24, 2014
    I vote stained! Add a level of interest, and you can always change it back if you don't like it :) If you do it be sure to post it to Hometalk I'd love to see the after!

  • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 24, 2014
    Hannah, you know I will! I was just saying that I'm having withdrawals from our old home built in 1919, it had soo much character. I'm trying to think of things I can do to with some character back. Hometalk is full of ideas. Ty for your opinion!

  • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 24, 2014
    • I'm trying to think of things I can do to this home to add some character•

  • Cindy D. Cindy D. on Sep 24, 2014
    I think it is very pretty as is, thought I imagine it would be lovely stained, as well. Curious, though - would you have to sand it all down to stain it? You couldn't just stain over the paint, could you?

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 24, 2014
      Cindy, I don't think you'd have to sand it down, I think if you would do that it's take the texture off since it isn't actually wood-but I know nothing. :)

  • Marion Nesbitt Marion Nesbitt on Sep 24, 2014
    Lovely big home. Looks new. I'd leave the doors as is just now and opt for spending the money on planting a couple of trees, getting some monster black urns for flowers.

    • See 1 previous
    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 24, 2014
      There's more, just not photos. I have the brick you see on the top left to wrap around that side and around that back filled with hydrangeas, sage, wisteria, Christmas trees, and some plants I got from my grandmother in FL.

  • JessieMacD JessieMacD on Sep 25, 2014
    I like them painted. Maybe try some hardware?

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      I knew we were going to use hardware, just looking to give it more character. That's a nice door you posted. Ty!

  • Edna Canas Edna Canas on Sep 25, 2014
    do it, if you don't like it, at least you can change it, but I think it fades away as it is now.

  • Linda Sharp Linda Sharp on Sep 25, 2014
    I like it painted, it blends in so well with the rest of the house. If you change to a stained doors it will make them stand out and the garage doors will dominate the look of the house. Garage doors should not be the focus of your home.

  • Petunia Petunia on Sep 25, 2014
    I think your biggest satisfaction would come in creating a large and beautiful planting bed with colorful tree leading towards your front door. That will make the door the focal point and take attention away from the massiveness of the garage doors. Leaving the garage doors as is will help them blend in, rather than making them a focal point. Good luck!

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      We have a maple that you cannot see in here. Right now, all those perennials are quite big.

  • Liliana Wells Liliana Wells on Sep 25, 2014
    I'd say they would be better painted to blend in with the rest of the house. I don't like it when the garage stands out.

  • V Valencia V Valencia on Sep 25, 2014
    I remember hearing on that HGTV program, Curb Appeal, that you should make your front door the focal point of your home because you want to draw eyes there. That is why you see people using an accent color on their doors and creating interest with potted plants, etc. at the entry.

    • See 3 previous
    • V Valencia V Valencia on Sep 25, 2014
      @Amber Thach Yes, I noticed your red front door, but I think if you stain your garage doors, you'll take attention away from your front door. In my opinion, when I look at your house, the trim stands out the most. I would go to a darker color, closer to the rest of the house. I think if you did that your front door would be more eye catching. It will look nice whichever way you go.

  • XEllle XEllle on Sep 25, 2014
    Since the trim on the rest of the house looks so nice, you might think about adding interest to the garage door by incorporating matching trim. And, just a thought about staining: maybe wait until the garage door really needs to be painted? Looks quite nice for now.

  • Lorraine-Lori Johns Lorraine-Lori Johns on Sep 25, 2014
    For the best Feng Shui of your house- leave it painted. The garage doors should not be a focal point of the house. The front door should be your focal point. Leave it painted, as it blends in with everything else.

  • Louis.hargrove Louis.hargrove on Sep 25, 2014
    I would leave it like it is I put hardware on my door and it is beautiful it makes a statement.

  • Linda Linda on Sep 25, 2014
    I think the garage looks quite nice as is, but I guess it is kind of over-powering your front door. The landscaping around the front door is certainly helping. Maybe staining the concrete drive would tone that area down and funnel the eye into your lovely front entrance.

  • Lezlie Lezlie on Sep 25, 2014
    Staining them would give your home a richer look. Can your front door also be stained to match??

  • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
    A lot of the houses around us are kind if ginger bread like and then you have ours.

  • Bibi Sweet67 Bibi Sweet67 on Sep 25, 2014
    I like it painted but maybe paint it the same color of your front door to give it a pop of color. Love the color of your front door.

  • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
    Beatrice, unfortunately where we live we have to have earth tones. No red garages! :)

  • MaryAnn B MaryAnn B on Sep 25, 2014
    Since you have a lot of garage door on the front of your house I would leave it the color it is since it blends in. Perhaps urns with flowers in front on each side and I also agree with the curving flower bed to the left to mimic the curve of the sidewalk.

  • Brianna Stieby Brianna Stieby on Sep 25, 2014
    I thinking painting it to match the trim would be best. The house is so dark as it is and it could use some brightening up.

  • Gail Gail on Sep 25, 2014
    i like it the way it is just need landscaping around the house.

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      Hi Gail, I like it too, but I have to be doing something. Possibly some hardware. I've posted pics in the previous comments in regards to the landscaping. We've done all of it this summer. :)

  • Melinda Columbus Melinda Columbus on Sep 25, 2014
    I would try planters @ garage doors in a contrasting color & landscape from the drive to the front door with easy care plants first. Then if I was still not satisfied with the chg I would revisit either painting the garage the trim or a contrasting color or stain. Maybe brighten the front door area.

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      Melinda, brightening the front door is a good idea. We do have planters and the yard is now landscaped. With the red rustic door I kind have been limited t what I should plant, but I started planting different colored perennials and they look great.

  • Centrd Centrd on Sep 25, 2014
    A pergola over the garage door painted to match your trim would be gorgeous. Not that big of a job, either. Plant some flowering vines and it would be so pretty. I know they say the garage shouldn't be the focal point on a house, but I've seen some gorgeous garages that I'd be more than happy to feature, so make the most of what you've got!

  • Centrd Centrd on Sep 25, 2014
    A couple more with natural wood, the other with a pergola that extends over the entry way as well.

    • See 10 previous
    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 28, 2014
      Hi Centrd, It was not planned. Everyone bought their own lot and built their own home with some restrictions in place since the land was foreclosed and bank owned. You've been very helpful. Thank you.

  • Bobbi Bobbi on Sep 25, 2014
    I would paint it a lighter color to much brown right now

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      Bobbi, it's kind of difficult to distinguish the colors from the main photo. It's more olive than brown. It might look good with trim color and hardware.

  • Larry Chura Larry Chura on Sep 25, 2014
    Since they do match the house color, why don't you continue with a painted brick pattern to the same height as the existing bricks. You can then put faces of children or animals looking over the top outwards towards the street.

  • Lisa Schoeffler Lisa Schoeffler on Sep 25, 2014
    You can gel stain your garage doors. You can apply the stain directly to them as they are. It will make them look a little aged and rustic, staying with the earth tones.

    • Amber Thach Amber Thach on Sep 25, 2014
      Lisa, great idea. I never thought of this or heard. Do you know which brand would be best?

  • Bonnie S Bonnie S on Sep 25, 2014
    I would just frame out the garage door windows and glass divide lines in the trim color on both doors, add some black iron and glass scones on both the sides of the main garage door and at least one by the house door.(even if you never use them or have them hooked up to power) then add the landscaping with something black in it too.

    • See 2 previous
    • Bonnie S Bonnie S on Sep 25, 2014
      @Amber Thach think like decorating inside...little things that pop/attract

  • Cynthia Cynthia on Sep 25, 2014
    I like it as is. If you stain or paint a different color it would draw attention away from the house...would end up being the focal point...the first thing you notice...unless that's what you had in mine. You might just add some bright , contrasting landscaping to the left of the door and maybe up the sidewalk. Lots of potential..good luck

  • Lezlie Lezlie on Sep 25, 2014
    So many fantastic suggestions...Please post photos of your decisions :)

    • See 1 previous
    • Angelina Angelina on Mar 23, 2015
      @Amber Thach Just check w/Rules & Regulations first :) I lived in a condo and some people complaint because they couldn't just do whatever they wanted, but it works for the better also, You should have seen the colors some people wanted to use. OMG!

  • Jeannie Darnell Jeannie Darnell on Sep 26, 2014
    You could paint it to match your front door. I think it looks good the way it is though.

  • Centrd Centrd on Sep 26, 2014
    @ Amber, I like gel stain in some situations where you don't want to strip the existing finish. , But to make a non wood door look like there's wood grain, you're going to have to do a faux treatment. Do a google search for "gel stain faux wood garage door" and you'll see some amazing examples. But just understand it's going to take a lot of work and some skill to get it too look like that. But like I said before, if you don't like it, you can always paint it back the way it was. Here are a couple of photos of gel stained faux wood doors that were done well. When you do the above search you can find a lot of tutorials on how to do it.

    • See 2 previous
    • Angelina Angelina on Mar 23, 2015
      @Centrd I love the wood-look it doesn't look fake. Wow!

  • Bonnie S Bonnie S on Sep 27, 2014
    Whatever you decide to do make sure you have that color someplace else. You have a lovely home as is too. The wooden doors across the street look nice but they also need to have the wooden door on the they don't look out of place/off balance.

  • Shari Shari on Sep 27, 2014
    I worked at a paint store for years and know what you mean about HOA restrictions. What I did with my house was paint the trim around the door the same color as the door itself. It make the door sort of "disappear". I got a lot of compliments on it, but I realize it's not to everyone's taste.

  • Janet Smith Janet Smith on Sep 27, 2014
    I would not paint or stain the doors darker than the house. It would make the doors the focal point of your home instead of the house. Paint them the same color as the paint on the house to make them less obvious.

  • Linda Linda on Oct 21, 2014
    I have never been a big fan on driving up to a home and the first thing that hits you is the garage doors. So I would do what ever to make them blend in to the house. Or get some really fancy old time hardware and paint them Black so they really stand out. That is just me. Good Luck with what ever you do.

  • Kelly French Johnson Kelly French Johnson on Nov 30, 2014
    @Amber Thach .. Your home is gorgeous but I think staining the doors a nice rich somewhat dark color would make the brick pop and look very. very classy!! Good luck!

  • Angelina Angelina on Mar 23, 2015
    I like the trellis idea so the flowers are the attraction, not the garage door.