Is spray in insulation really better than bat insulation?
-
Nichter's Home Services Corp on Nov 03, 2011Absolutely! Open celled foam is marginally better, but closed cell foams are 2-3 times as good. Not only do they provide far better R-value against radiant heat loss, but they totally stop infiltration and convective heat loss. Added benefit is that they make a home quieter and provide a vapor barrier to help manage indoor humidity.Helpful Reply
-
-
3po3 on Nov 03, 2011Agree with Nichter. Also, spray insulation can get into gaps and holes better than batts.Helpful Reply
-
-
Woodbridge Environmental Tiptophouse.com on Nov 04, 2011Dollar per dollar, spray foam properly applied will give you a pay back in savings on an average home in about six years over the cost of fiberglass. It makes the house air tight, makes it more energy efficient, It makes the house stronger and controls moisture when using the closed cell system. Although about twice the cost or in some cases three times the cost of fiberglass it is simply a better system overall. But if your on a budget, there are methods of using fiberglass and air sealing foam to achieve some of the benefits of both, Air sealing and lower install cost. A system that we use is called Ecoseal elastomeric sealant, this product is sprayed on and forms a tight seal on all wall joints and gaps. Check out http://ecoseal.knaufinsulation.us/kiss.html Its a sealant we use on all gaps and openings in a home, then we batt insulate or after walls are up blow insulation into cavities.Helpful Reply
-
-
Dwyer Industries, Inc. on Nov 04, 2011I agree with Woodbridge Environmental. Payback is about 6 years. In new construction payback is much less because you can design total system from scratch thereby reducing A/C size. Not every existing home is a candidate for spray foam. You need to have access to everywhere! Also, be careful that our AC unit is variable speed. Your existing unit will be too large in an existing home and a varaiable spped unit will help with that.Helpful Reply
-
-
Ace Solves It All on Nov 10, 2011i agree with Dwyer Industries he is correct and it works very well when installed properlyHelpful Reply
-
-
HANDY HUSBAND, The on Nov 12, 2011Correct me if I'm wrong. Closed-cell insulation would be for the walls, but Open-cell spray for the roof rafters. The reason being if a roof leak was present it would make itself known to the homeowner.Helpful Reply
-
-
Woodbridge Environmental Tiptophouse.com on Nov 13, 2011No Ideally closed cell should be used for the roof at least for the first few inches. If a leak occurs on the roof, you do not want the open cell foam to absorb it. Closed cell insulation acts as a vapor barrier better then the open cell stuff. You can get away with the open cell as well, but the R value of the closed cell is a bit higher per inch then the open cell type. Regardless of open or closed if a leak occurs on a roof it will not show up near the spot where it is leaking anyway. The roof should be in good shape and properly maintained. What my guy uses is about two inches of closed cell then on the 2nd pass uses open cell as its about $1 per foot less to install. As far as walls, floors and roofs. Open cell expands and and flexes better as the framing moves with wind and settlement. This is the preferred material for residential construction.Helpful Reply
-
-
HANDY HUSBAND, The on Nov 13, 2011Very good Woodbridge. I am glad I asked the question for your follow-up answer. Thank You. LouHelpful Reply
-
-
Nichter's Home Services Corp on Nov 13, 2011I hear of numerous instances of open celled foam holding water and causing mold and rot.Helpful Reply
-
-
Dwyer Industries, Inc. on Nov 14, 2011I thnk closed cell is a better product for the Northern States, but in hot humid climates especially in hurricane zones I prefer the open cell product. Their are many open questions concerning long term effects of using closed cell when leaks occur. My experience through the hurricanes has been that the open cell foam (which is waterblown) gets wet and over a week to ten days after the damage completely dries out. I had several customers that had trees fall on their homes and exposed the open cell foam and there was no long term problems. Also, while most closed cell foam are R6.5-7.0 per inch and open cells are 3.5-4.0 per inch, R Value is just a matter of spraying the open cell thicker. Either way, I thnk for new costruction, spray foam is the best alternative. In response to Nichters concern about holding water and causing mold and rot, most of the oepn cell foams are hydophobic. I have experienced the soy based foams not drying out and turning into a type of pea soup consistency when it gets wet, but that was about 5 years ago. There are some applications that open cell should not be used in, namely in crawl space conditions where there could be mositure migration from the ground.Helpful Reply
-
Related Discussions
Which mattress firmness do you prefer: soft or hard?
Finding the perfect mattress can be a game-changer for your sleep quality and overall health.So, we're curious: When it comes to mattress firmness, what’s your pref... See more
Cleaning mineral deposits off of glass
How do I remove mineral deposits from windows??? I've tried cleaning with vinegar on both the inside & outside of the windows...is it possible it's on the inside of t... See more
What to hang over fireplace?
Right now I have a cream colored berry wreath over my fireplace. I will be getting the picture shown over my sofa ( that is a mock up so size won't be exact). Do you... See more
Clean grout hard (iron) water stains?
We have a shower that has laminate side and flooring. The areas were grout is has turned orange/Black. I have used vinegar applied with toothbrush, Granite Gold grout... See more
Toilet: Rumbling / Vibrating Noise when FILLING up (SMOOTH when flush)
When flushing the toilet, no problem, smooth flush like all others, no issues. (My 1st inclination of the noise when filling up was a clogged toilet, but it flushes q... See more
How clean grout from a brick ?
hello all, I just moved to my new APT and I was working on my new kitchen. part of the work is to glue the bricks on the wall 1 centimeter apart so that the grout ... See more
I need a fabric stiffener that is weather resistant. Any ideas?
I created a fabric wreath and have tried two different brands of fabric stiffeners that have failed, any help appreciated.