Fireplace tile makeover

Hello, I want to change the look on our gas fireplace. It has porous 6" tiles, and some smooth and porous, longer tiles along the border. See attached.Thanks for the input! - Stephanie
q fireplace tile, fireplaces mantels, home decor, home decor dilemma, tiling
  17 answers
  • Janet Pizaro Janet Pizaro on Jan 25, 2016
    Although your fireplace surround is not painted this idea sounded interesting.

  • Becky Becky on Jan 25, 2016
    What are you going to do with the wall around it?

  • MN Mom MN Mom on Jan 25, 2016
    Your tile work is gorgeous and was probably an expensive installation. What is it that you don't like...color? Texture?

  • Moxie Moxie on Jan 25, 2016
    You might want to look into products to change the grout color to brighten up the install.

  • Johnchip Johnchip on Jan 26, 2016
    I agree, something is just not right. I would first try painting some or all tiles, trying to make use of the varied shapes and sizes. (it is the black I find most offensive and the black pitting. This might be solved with wiping in a neutral color and wiping it off the surface of the pitted ones. Paint /re-Grout then in a complimentary color to the walls. All this before gutting it out, it was not cheap and you risk losing house value if replaced cheaply.

  • Sheila D Sheila D on Jan 26, 2016
    Do you want to keep tiles or hide them? Have seen a few of DIY and remodel shows updating with subway or mosaic tiles. Take & print pics & sketch in different looks. Send us pic of your results.

  • MN Mom MN Mom on Jan 26, 2016
    Stephanie would you please post a picture of the whole front of the fireplace? I have a friend who designs tile and I would like to share it with her to help with ideas. She does work for HGTV and has a tile product line. Thanks!

  • LD LD on Jan 26, 2016
    Instead of removing the time, you could paint the time, which would give it a different color, but you would still have the same design look. If you are going for a brand new design look for your fireplace, you could remove the existing tile, and then build or buy a wood mantle. Here's a link to a company that makes all kind of fireplace mantles, just make sure to go with a design that is timeless.*SizedToFit&kw=fireplace%20facade*e&gclid=Cj0KEQiAz5y1BRDZ4Z_K_eGa84cBEiQAtQkeaMCBv6ECpkRiitbdthvwWGsMketho-MCAQ6bZZvLYwcaAuO48P8HAQ

  • Susan Susan on Jan 26, 2016
    Without a bigger photo, it is hard to determine the age of your home. These look like they might be authentic Craftsman handmade tiles. If so, please research first before touching them! If authentic, you could probably sell for enough money to do whatever you want on your fireplace surround. And these vintage tiles will be saved.

    • See 1 previous
    • Susan Susan on Jan 26, 2016
      @MN Mom LOL if this were my fireplace, I would decorate my entire room around it! Some don't appreciate the Craftsman or Arts & Crafts era and it's simple elegance and handmade aesthetic. Very rare to see fireplace tiles still in place.

  • Ranger Ranger on Jan 26, 2016
    Maybe stipple them. You can make fake 'cracked and aged looking' picture frames and other stuff so it may look good on your fire hearth too?

  • Kathy Meador Wells Kathy Meador Wells on Jan 26, 2016
    If they are not authentic craftsman tiles you probably could paint them for a one color unified look.

  • MN Mom MN Mom on Jan 26, 2016
    Showed my expert the tile and she said she does not believe it is Craftsman era due to the travertine and smaller rectangle tiles pictured. Most tiles then were hand made ceramic and were not as uniform as these. She cautions on painting this as the intricate installation is a quality investment. Painted tiles too often look like painted tiles.

  • Junebugtx Junebugtx on Jan 31, 2016
    I would suggest painting the tiles as well tather than taking down the original ones. They so look like craftsman tiles. Good luck. Hope you post your results.

  • Junebugtx Junebugtx on Jan 31, 2016
    Actually, more like the Arts & Crafts style. I think it's really cool.

  • Kerry Kerry on Jan 31, 2016
    Kerry N. Richmond, VA If you want to remove the tiles use a hammer and chisel. Use a good belt sander to clean up and make even the area the tiles were on. I'd pick Carrera thin marble tiles so you wouldn't have to worry about the weight of the marble falling off during the project. Use Muscle Bound Tile Adhesive Sheet to hold the tiles in place; make sure you have the spacers for the grout in. Once you have the tiles where you want use unsanded grout to finish. Then you're ready to put the marble framing on the same way.

  • Susan Rawlings Susan Rawlings on Feb 26, 2016
    Have you thought of refacing with tile--a new tile? That's a very hot trend right now.

  • Jcraw Jcraw on Oct 22, 2016
    I'm no help. I think it's fabulous. I'd attempt to repair myself, and have pro come and finish and seal it. Needs be, depending on the size of the wall, I would add a wider solid tile border around the whole thing, probably black. Like a picture frame. It is art of the era and the craftsman who designed it.