What can I use to cover a fireplace that's not usable ?

Mary Knorr
by Mary Knorr
have a piece of plastic sheet and regular plastic covering it because damper doesn't close the best
  12 answers
  • Kate Kate on Sep 22, 2017

    Type in fireplace remodels in the "find your next project" spot in Hometalk. LOTS of ideas. You will need to seal it up. I liked the wood circle idea, and there is a gorgeous fireplace screen from Plow and Hearth in stained glass; you could get a piece of glass or an old window and paint a design on it to put in front of the fireplace with lights behind it. Paint it and put a faux log in it. There are firebox inserts run by electricity or gas that you can insert. Have fun!!

  • Charlotte Charlotte on Sep 22, 2017

    I painted my fireplace as I do not use it living in Florida and put house plants in front of it or if dark room put a decorative scren that has a mural on it.

  • Why not highlight it and make it a focal point with a binch of candles or a small state of some sort? Or just board it up and tile over it.

  • Fiddledd224 Fiddledd224 on Sep 22, 2017

    Have you considered buying a fireplace insert? They are very affordable and safe. You can place it in the existing fire box and can change the surround with any material. You can use tile, stone, stucco, etc. in any texture since the fireplace isn't using a flame.

  • Lisa S. Lisa S. on Sep 22, 2017

    I am guessing that you have plastic over it as the flue is or chimney is damaged. I had this issue for a few years on my masonry / brick fireplace until I bought the bullet ($7,000) and paid to have the whole thing taken down and rebuilt. ...In the mean time - they make a product that is insulating that goes up into the empty space, to insulate it. I did this, then added glass fireplace doors which blocked off more of the air coming in. I then had a decorative brass fan that spread out in front of the doors and it looked very nice. No one was the wiser, that it did not work. I also used clear tape to seal off the doors completely.

  • Swan Road Designs Swan Road Designs on Sep 24, 2017

    If you don't plan to use the fireplace for ambiance or heat, have the chimney sealed. Then clean the inside of the fireplace and spray paint the inside flat black. Use the open space to house a decorative wrought iron candle stand or seasonal flower arrangements.

  • Sally Boyne Sally Boyne on Sep 24, 2017

    Melectric logs r nice

  • Michele Michele on Sep 24, 2017

    maybe if you have a big slab a wood you can paint a fire or just logs on. I've seen people just put candles in a non working fireplace

  • Shawnda Shawnda on Sep 25, 2017

    We have a large rectangular piece of styrofoam that I wrapped in black felt fabric. It goes behind my fireplace screen when we aren't using it. It insulates the room.

  • Sharon Sharon on Sep 25, 2017

    I've usually seen reclaimed wood covers with some folk art painted on it, but this Pinterest has some good ideas..... I like the faux wood one..... https://www.pinterest.com/dreamrose50/fireplace-screens-covers/?lp=true

    I also like the faux window using an old window... https://i.pinimg.com/736x/49/5b/5e/495b5e144bd8379a4af479c356f1a79e--window-panes-window-art.jpg

    I like the bookcase idea.... https://i.pinimg.com/736x/c4/cd/22/c4cd22298edb068db19e52eeb0aa9dfb--fake-fireplace-fireplace-bookshelves.jpg

    I also had my fireplace removed from my 1940s home, and it cost $10k, and I had a faux tile fireplace built inside in the 5' wide space with herringbone large 26"x6" tiles with an electric fireplace/heater insert.... with a remote.

  • Janice Janice on Oct 26, 2023

    You could have a piece of plywood or even drywall cut to size and then either stain, paint, or stencil a design onto it and then adhere it to the existing wood portion to seal it off better and also create a conversation piece.

  • Betsy Betsy on Oct 26, 2023

    Hi Mary: Well, what you can do is get a nice fireplace screen to put in front of it, or an insert. Or, close off the shields in the chimney that let the smoke out, and clean and paint the bricks inside of the fireplace. Then put an arrangement of fake flowers or whatever else you may like in there.