Suggestions for stair rail ?

I live in a home built in the 1980’s. I have builders grade hand rails on the stairs. They are 5 1/2 “ wide. I hard to get a good grip. I’d like to replace just the rail piece with something I can wrap my hand around. The stair wood balusters are attached to 3 1/2” (w) wood top and bottom. Hopefully could just replace the top rail. I can’t find anything to go on top the wood. Help!

michele

Stairs.

You can see how the stair balusters are attached to the wood.

Under top stair rail.

  14 answers
  • Judy in Canton. Judy in Canton. on Jun 28, 2021

    Is it possible to run a rail along the inside of this rail instead of trying to place it?

  • FrugalFamilyTimes.com FrugalFamilyTimes.com on Jun 28, 2021

    Are you looking to do this yourself? Because a local company can surely make a handrail for you that’s exactly what you’re looking for. You can find premade handrails too - try your local building centre. which could be a pretty straightforward install.

    • Michele Lucostic Michele Lucostic on Jun 30, 2021

      Yes I am looking to do this myself. Yes I could have a company come in and do it however trying to save $$

  • Dee Dee on Jun 28, 2021

    Do you have a builders Surplus in your area. Our Surplus store carries very nice hand rails and then you can have a handyman install.

  • William William on Jun 28, 2021

    It looks like the top and bottom rails are 2X6's. The newel post and baluster rails look like 1X4's or 2X4's. It looks like the newel post, top and bottom rails were installed first. Then the balusters and baluster rails. Cheap looking stair rail but it did pass code. You might be able to remove the top rail and replace it with "real" top rail. Look for any screws or nails from underneath. You could use a stiff putty knife at the bottom of the staircase just to see if it can be pried off. If it can, use a razor utility knife and cut through the paint between the top rail and baluster rail.

    • Michele Lucostic Michele Lucostic on Jun 30, 2021

      The stair rail is prefab builders grade. The top and bottom are 3 1/2” wide the balusters are connected to the top and bottom pieces. It comes to the site in one piece. Then they slap a 5 1/2” board on top. I do believe I can remove the top piece.

  • Vimarhonor Vimarhonor on Jun 28, 2021

    Hello. I wonder if it might be wrapped with something to make it more attractive and substantial?

  • Sharon Sharon on Jun 28, 2021

    They make a railing that is semi-rounded on top with grooves on the side for finger grips https://www.lowes.com/pd/2-25-in-x-8-ft-Unfinished-Red-Oak-Wood-Handrail/1000514273 I was surprised how much more secure I felt using it.

    • See 1 previous
    • Sharon Sharon on Jul 03, 2021

      I assumed you would be removing all that excess wood, and drilling insets in the railing to set your upright spindles/dowels into the railing. I check on my supplier website, nothing over 2 5/8" wide on the bottom.


      You could have a woodworker shave 1/4" off each side of the old spindle cap to accommodate the new top railing.


      You could otherwise have a custom woodworker make you a larger rounded top rail to fit the old dowel wood cap. I've personally never seen larger/wider stair rails.... but shop around online and see if you can find one.



    • Michele Lucostic Michele Lucostic on Jun 30, 2021

      I have seen this done and LOVE it. However the aesthetic would not match my decor. It would stick out like a sore thumb.

  • Rymea Rymea on Jun 29, 2021

    You could put the handrail on the inside. I think all you need is a handrail and "handrail brackets" which you can get anywhere.

    You might want to think about painting the balusters black for a more modern look.

  • You can replace just the handrail with one that's more comfortable. They sell them at Home Depot and Lowe's. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfR2KIdndPo

    • Michele Lucostic Michele Lucostic on Jun 30, 2021

      I have looked and looked for a hand rail that would properly work on-top of the 3 1/2” piece all of hand rails are too small. 😕

  • William William on Jun 30, 2021

    If the top rail is removable, you can add a spacer between the 3 1/2" baluster rail and the top rail. This would raise the top rail and would be easy to grip. It would look something like an I beam. I drew a profile pic

  • Agnes Chrzanowska Agnes Chrzanowska on Jun 30, 2021

    i wouldn't attempt that all by yourself .. seek a professional help

  • Can you run a rail up the wall side? Or the rail went together so it should come apart at which point you could replace it. Shop around, I’m sure there’s a size that will fit and if not, you can put pieces together to get what you need. It might not be an easy project managing those lengths, FYI.

  • Kmdreamer Kmdreamer on Jul 01, 2021

    You could find someone to carve out wood to just go over that rail

  • Deb K Deb K on Apr 06, 2022

    Hi Michele, go to your local home improvement store and buy a handrail for stairs in the length you need, they are nice and narrow to grip, then screw that to the top of existing rail that is there, being sure to center it nicely, then paint it to match the existing handrail. Hope this helps