It depends what your fireplace is made of. Most can be painted, and it would definitely be cost effective. But, it ultimately depends on your personal style and budget.
We replaced our old marble mantel & now I would like to repurpose it. The piece measures 8" x 1 1/4" x 6'. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
No one knows your taste but you. Painting is quicker.
It depends what your fireplace is made of. Most can be painted, and it would definitely be cost effective. But, it ultimately depends on your personal style and budget.
Your fireplace is brick now, or tile?
Brick
This video will show you what is involved:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69UX9mGsv1A