Refinishing a Bench and How to Make a No-sew Tufted Cushion

8 Materials
2 Hours

My grandparents’ built this bench YEARS ago along with two others that I have. ( Check out the cedar-lined beauty I keep at the end of my bed.) This one has taken the biggest beating over the years and has needed to be fixed and refinished for awhile now. Every month the group I’m a part of (the Farmhouse Hens Decorate) has a theme. This month’s theme turned out to be for benches so I knew exactly the piece I would be using!
Those bite marks are actually from my dog Diesel lol
Funny, he was a 120 pound mastiff and could have easily opened the lid with his nose anytime he wanted. (I kept his food and treats in there.) If he had just helped himself to a treat I never would have known but no he just chewed on it lol
So I started by cleaning it really well with vinegar and water before assessing the damage.
I knew I needed to at least get the top coat of poly off so I first hit every surface with fine grit sandpaper using my orbital palm sander. I planned on staining it the same color it already was so I didn’t take it all the way back to naked wood.
With stain-able wood filler I carefully filled in the holes and any other imperfections I could find. (Yes, filling those chew marks in made me kind of sad. Diesel’s been gone for over two years now and I still miss him.)
A little more sanding to smooth out the wood filler and than I stained the bench in Dark Walnut (by Minwax) by generously brushing the stain on, waiting twenty minutes, and then wiping it off with a towel.

I put a coat of satin poly acrylic over my stain and my bench looked almost like new!
I’ve had it in my head for awhile now that I wanted a cushion here because I sit on it almost every day to put my shoes on! The thing is though – I don’t have a sewing machine and I am incredibly not a seamstress SO I decided to figure out how to make a cushion lacking all sewing ability whatsoever.
First, I cut a piece of plywood three inches smaller than the lid of the bench. I drilled six holes in the top of the plywood (evenly spaced) for the buttons.
(Years ago I had a sleep number bed that died and left me with mounds of batting, foam and lots and lots of cushiony stuff. This is AT LEAST the third time I’m glad I kept it all! Batting is expensive!)
I cut the batting to the size of the seat so its wider than the plywood by about an inch and a half all the way around. I then poked up through each of the holes and cut the batting out around them so my buttons would really SINK.
(My Grandma left behind a lifetime’s worth of buttons so I went through them and pulled out the six biggest ones that would work best here – I made no effort to make sure that they matched lol I liked it random.)
I secured my buttons with cotton kitchen twine by pulling them tight to really create my tufts and then stapling the twine to the back.
With the buttons complete I secured the fabric with staples along the underside edge of the plywood all the way around.
Tah-dah! I love my new cushion and it was SO easy to make!
Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Hometalk may collect a small share of sales from the links on this page. More info

Top Hometalk Projects

31 Space-Saving DIY Ideas That'll Keep Your Home Organized
30 Creative Painting Techniques & Ideas You MUST See!
15 Genius Curtain Ideas To Instantly Upgrade Your Space
Fake It Until You Make It! 27 Creative Hacks for High-End Looks
15 Genius Curtain Ideas To Instantly Upgrade Your Space
15 Things To Do With Scrap Material
15 Gorgeous Bohemian Inspired Decor Items To Make For Yourself
18 Fun Ways To Add Glitter To Your Home Decor
16 Creative Ways To Upcycle Pallets
31 Amazing Furniture Flips You Have to See to Believe
14 Cool Ways To Upholster Chairs That You Can DIY
31 Amazing Furniture Flips You Have to See to Believe
30 Reasons We Can’t Stop Buying Michaels Storage Crates
14 DIY Hacks to Stay Clean While Camping
16 Ways to Showcase Your Herb Garden

Want more details about this and other DIY projects? Check out my blog post!


Have a question about this project?

2 questions
  • Patti
    on Sep 18, 2018

    🤔 What does cleaning wood furniture with vinegar & water do? I use vinegar & water for many things but have never used it for cleaning wood furniture. What ratio do you recommend? Is it safe to use on expensive a grand piano?

    TIA 🙂

    • Theresa Taylor
      on Jan 1, 2020

      WOW! That was an awful experience for your whole family. Was so upset the birds, and the puppy and fish all died that way. Pain that would linger for a long, long time. Praise God for your protection when opening the door. The what ifs are too scary to dwell on.

      was not aware of your carpet saving method. Great save.

  • Robert Shall
    on Sep 22, 2018

    I have a heating pipe (riser) in my bathroom. It is old and all rusted. How can I get old paint and rust off and repaint to make itlook newer?

Join the conversation

3 of 46 comments
  • Dorothy Sittler
    on Dec 31, 2019

    What a great way to remember your grandparents! I am glad that you kept the same look.

  • Norma Baudin
    on Jan 2, 2020

    Hi!! Thank you so much for answering me! 😊 Peg board sounds perfect as it's not as heavy and certainly sounds easier to work with! (No drilling lol) I have say that I was just looking through the tour of your house and you did an absolutely amazing job! Your house is beautiful!! Thank you for sharing! Have a beautiful day!! 😊🌹

Your comment...