The 8 Best Comforters of 2021

By Corrie Pelc


The bed is a sacred place — it’s where you go to rest, dream, and wake up ready to start a brand new day. Because of that, the type of bedding you choose is important as it can mean the difference between a restful night’s sleep or a night of tossing and turning. That’s why we made a comprehensive guide of the best comforters you can buy.


In the bedding world, the comforter is the icing on the bed cupcake. It’s the soft, fluffy topper that you can snuggle down under and melt into, letting you drift peacefully into sleep. It has an important role to play in your sleep quality, so finding the right comforter for your bed is important.


What is the Difference Between a Comforter and a Duvet?

When shopping for comforters, you may stumble upon the term duvet used almost interchangeably with comforter. We're here to help explain things:







  • A comforter is a top layer of bedding that can be used as-is right out of the packaging to add comfort and warmth to your bed.
  • A duvet is a two-piece part of the bedding that consists of a duvet insert and duvet cover. The duvet insert is meant to be the "fill" for the duvet cover and will have loops on it to attach to the duvet cover. The duvet cover is generally designed with colors, patterns, etc. to bring an aesthetic appeal to your bedroom.


Where things get potentially confusing is that some comforters can be used as duvet inserts. For example, some of the comforters on our top-rated list have loops on them that allow them to be attached to a duvet cover. Since many comforters only come in white or a limited color selection, being able to attach them to a duvet cover gives you more color and pattern options.


How to Find the Best Comforter

With so many prices and options out there today, it can be tough to figure out what type of comforter is best for your sleep style. To help narrow down the field, here are the testing factors we’ve employed to help you find the right comforter for your needs:







  • Price: With so many price points available in the world of comforters, knowing what you’re getting for your money is important.
  • Warmths: Some comforters will come in various “warmths” — light, medium, and heavy — for different seasons and your climates.
  • Available Sizes: Sizes for comforters can range anywhere from twin to California king.
  • Construction: Traditionally speaking, there are two ways that comforters are constructed — sewn-through and baffle box. With sewn-through construction, the top and bottom shell layers are sewn together, making pockets of filler throughout the comforter. People who like lightweight comforters or like to layer their comforter with other blankets and quilts typically enjoy sewn-through comforters. With baffle box, vertical strips of shell material are added, creating 3D boxes inside the comforter, which results in more airflow throughout the filler so it’s not as densely packed as with a sewn-through comforter. Baffle box comforters are great for those who sleep cold and like a substantial comforter to keep warm. Some comforters will have variations of these two constructions.
  • Shell Material: The comforter shell is the outermost fabric that encases the comforter filling, and is usually made of cotton, silk, or a polyester fabric or blend. The shell is often white or a light neutral color, although there are now a lot of comforters coming in various colors and patterns.
  • Filler Material: The filler of a comforter can be made with natural materials like goose or duck down (feathers), cotton, wool, or man-made fibers.
  • Duvet Loops: Does the comforter provide loops to be attached to a duvet cover?
  • Machine Washable: Some comforters can be washed in a washing machine, but others need special treatment for cleaning.
  • Certifications: Some comforters will have specific certifications like Oeko-Tex, which means the substances used to make the comforter are not harmful to you or the environment. And for down comforters, there is also a Responsible Down Standard (RDS) seal that shows the down was collected humanely.
  • Warranty & Sleep Trial: Due to their price, many comforters will come with a warranty against any defects in workmanship or materials. Additionally, some comforters will even come with a free sleep trial, meaning you can test the comforter out for a certain number of nights before deciding to keep it.


Without further ado, here’s a look at our top picks for the best comforters you can buy.


Best Down Comforter: Brooklinen Down Comforter

~ $143-$323 at Brooklinen


Our top pick when it comes to traditional down comforters.

best down comforter


When it comes to down comforters, the best you can buy right now is the Brooklinen Down Comforter. While a bit more on the expensive end — the largest King/Cali King will set you back a little over $300 — the quality and construction of this comforter makes it worth the investment. The comforter features a 100% cotton sateen shell and down cluster fill that is kept nice and lofty due to its baffle box construction. Available in three warmths — lightweight, all-season and ultra-warm — and three sizes, this comforter can make even the pickiest sleeper happy. The down comforter also has loops for attaching a duvet cover, is treated with antimicrobials, hypoallergenic, and is backed by a generous 365-day return policy. 


Ideal for: The pickiest of sleepers who want a down comforter that will tick all their boxes. 








  • Price: ~ $143-$323
  • Warmths: Lightweight, all-season, ultra-warm
  • Available Sizes: Twin/Twin XL; Full/Queen; King/Cali King
  • Construction: Baffle box
  • Shell Material: 100% cotton sateen shell
  • Filler Material: Down cluster
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: No 
  • Certifications: Down Comforters certified by the Down Association of Canada ( Downmark); Lightweight Down Comforters are filled with recycled duck and goose down and certified by Global Recycled Standard (GRS) and RDS
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: 365-day return policy


Pros: 







  • Quality construction and materials
  • Available in three warmths and three sizes
  • 365-day return policy


Cons: 







  • Only available in white
  • Dry clean only


Best Down Alternative Comforter: SUPERIOR Down Alternative Comforter

~ $38-$65 on Amazon 


A well-made and highly-rated down alternative comforter that comes in six colors and at an excellent price. 

best down alternative comforter



At under $100 with almost 5,000 reviews and 4.5 stars on Amazon, the SUPERIOR Down Alternative Comforter is a top pick for those considering a down alternative comforter. This comforter is an excellent choice for those who just want an all-season comforter with color options other than white. The comforter is built from a microfiber shell and baffle box construction that is double-stitched to ensure the comforter's fill stays well distributed and helps reduce cold areas. The comforter's polyester fill is hypoallergenic, making it a great pick for those who may be allergic to down. And to make things even better, the comforter is completely machine washable — just follow the instructions on the tag. 


Ideal for: Sleepers looking for a well-made down alternative comforter at a great price point in colors other than white. 








  • Price: ~ $38-$65
  • Warmths: All-season
  • Available Sizes: Twin/Twin XL; Full/Queen; King
  • Construction: Baffle box
  • Shell Material: Microfiber
  • Filler Material: Polyester
  • Duvet Loops: No
  • Machine Washable: Yes
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: Returnable through Amazon’s return policy


Pros: 







  • Economical price
  • Available in six colors 
  • Machine washable


Cons: 







  • Only available in one warmth
  • No duvet loops


Best Comforter Under $100: Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

~ $30-$75 on Amazon


A highly-rated down alternative comforter with lots of bells and whistles for under $100.

best comforter under $100


With more than 93,000 reviews and 4.5 stars on Amazon, you really can't go wrong with the Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter. With the largest-sized comforter at $75, this comforter is a great buy as it is available in a slew of sizes and colors/patterns, including some that are reversible. It also has eight built-in corner and side loops so it can easily be attached to a duvet cover. The comforter has a microfiber down alternative fill that is kept nice and fluffy through a box stitch design. Available in an all-season weight only, the comforter is machine washable and is backed by a three-year manufacturer warranty.


Ideal for: Budget-conscious shoppers who want a tried-and-true comforter for under $100. 








  • Price: ~ $30-$75
  • Warmths: All-season
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Oversized Queen, King, California King, Oversized King
  • Construction: Box stitch design
  • Shell Material: Microfiber
  • Filler Material: Microfiber down alternative
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: Yes
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: Three-year warranty; returnable through Amazon’s return policy


Pros: 







  • Under $100 for even the largest size
  • Lots of sizes and colors/patterns to choose from
  • Microfiber down alternative is great for those with allergies


Cons: 







  • Only one warmth available


Best Comforter for Hot Sleepers: Amerisleep Recover+ Comforter

~ $250-$350 at Amerisleep


An excellent comforter option for those who tend to run warm when sleeping. 

best comforter for hot sleepers


If you tend to run warm when you're sleeping, you know there's nothing worse than waking up in the middle of the night in a pool of your own sweat, overheated, and uncomfortable. The Amerisleep Recover+ Comforter is one of the best cooling comforters as it features a synthetic fiber called Celliant in the cover and fill that is designed to help regulate your body temperature. The comforter's fill also contains Lyocell — a fiber made from eucalyptus trees that also helps keep you cooler while you sleep, and its box stitch construction helps ensure the fill stays springy and well placed throughout the product. Available in a light grey — the Amerisleep Recover+ Comforter works well as an insert into a duvet cover that can be attached through its corner loops. It is machine washable and comes with a one-year limited warranty.


Ideal for: Hot sleepers who want a comforter that will keep them cool and comfy throughout the night. 








  • Price: $250-$350
  • Warmths: One warmth
  • Available Sizes: Twin XL, Full/Queen, King
  • Construction: Box stitched
  • Shell Material: Celliant and cotton
  • Filler Material: Celliant, lyocell, and polyester
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: Yes
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: One-year limited warranty


Pros: 







  • Designed to keep hot sleepers cool and comfortable
  • Duvet loops for attaching to a duvet cover
  • Machine washable


Cons: 







  • Only available in one warmth
  • Limited size options
  • Only available in one color


Best Eco-Friendly Comforter: Buffy Comforter

~ $129-$199 on Amazon


An excellent choice for the most environmentally conscious sleepers. 

best eco-friendly comforter


The Buffy Cloud Comforter not only provides superior warmth and comfort, but is the perfect pick for those who want an environmentally conscious product. The comforter is constructed from an extremely soft shell of eucalyptus fiber that the company says is grown using 10 times less water than cotton. And the company says its fill is made entirely from fibers made from recycled plastic bottles and that each comforter helps keep 50 plastic bottles out of landfills. This eco-friendly comforter uses a quilted stitched construction to keep the fill in place, and includes loops for easy insertion into a duvet cover. Although the manufacturer's website says the Buffy Cloud Comforter is machine washable, on Amazon the suggestion is to dry clean, so definitely read the tag before washing. 


Ideal for: Eco-conscious sleepers who want a down alternative comforter they can stand behind. 








  • Price: $129-$199
  • Warmths: One warmth
  • Available Sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Construction: Quilted stitching
  • Shell Material: 100% eucalyptus fiber
  • Filler Material: 100% recycled PET, BPA-free
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: Yes, but dry cleaning recommended
  • Certifications: Oeko-Tex certified
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: Seven-night sleep trial


Pros: 







  • Made entirely from eco-friendly fibers
  • Oeko-Tex certified
  • Offers a seven-night sleep trial


Cons: 







  • Only available in white
  • Only available in one warmth


Best Comforter for Sleepers with Allergies: Quince Premium Lightweight Down Alternative Comforter

~ $120-$130 at Quince 


Now those allergic to down can get the same feel and quality with this alternative-fill comforter. 

best comforter for sleepers with allergies


Sleepers with allergies rejoice — the Quince Premium Lightweight Down Alternative Comforter is a great option and an excellent price-point to keep you comfortable throughout the night. The comforter uses a hypoallergenic microfiber fill that makes you feel like you're under a comforter filled with goose down without the worry of an allergy attack. This bed topper also features a 100% cotton sateen shell to help keep hot sleepers cool, and a baffle box construction to ensure the filler stays lofty and evenly distributed throughout the comforter. The Quince Premium Lightweight Down Alternative Comforter can be placed within a duvet cover thanks to its included loops, and it comes with a 365-day return policy.  


Ideal for: Those who want the feel of a goose down comforter in an allergen-free product. 








  • Price: ~ $120-$130
  • Warmths: Lightweight only
  • Available Sizes: Full/Queen, King/Cal King
  • Construction: Baffle box
  • Shell Material: 100% cotton sateen
  • Filler Material: Hypo-allergenic microfiber fill
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: Yes
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: 365-day return policy


Pros: 







  • The feel of goose down in an allergy-free product
  • 365-day return policy
  • Machine washable


Cons: 







  • Not available in twin
  • Only available in white
  • Only available in lightweight


Best Comforter Set: Madison Park Palmer Cozy Comforter Set

~ $106-$122 on Amazon 


A highly-rated comforter with pillows, pillow shams, and a bed skirt to match.

best comforter set


If you want your pillows and throw pillows to match your new comforter, then definitely check out the Madison Park Palmer Cozy Comforter Set. This top-rated comforter set comes in five colorways and features a silky faux suede comforter, two matching pillow shams, three throw pillows, and a bed skirt. The comforter shell is made from a pieced microsuede that’s not only soft but resists wrinkles and shrinking in the wash. The comforter uses a down alternative filler made from a polyester filling and is lightweight enough to make it suitable for all times of the year.


Ideal for: Sleepers who like everything on their bed to match. 








  • Price: ~ $106-$122 
  • Warmths: One warmth
  • Available Sizes: Full, Queen, King, Cal King
  • Construction: Stitching technique not specified
  • Shell Material: Polyester faux suede
  • Filler Material: Polyester
  • Duvet Loops: No
  • Machine Washable: Yes
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: Returnable through Amazon’s return policy


Pros: 







  • Budget-friendly price for all that’s offered
  • Includes comforter and two matching pillow shams, three throw pillows, and a bed skirt
  • Comes in five colors and four sizes


Cons: 







  • Only one weight available
  • Style may not fit all bedrooms or tastes


Best Luxury Comforter: L.L. Bean Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter

~ $399-$589 at L.L.Bean


A top-of-the-line comforter that will make any sleeper feel special. 

best luxury comforter


If a comforter is one thing you’re ready to splurge on, then the L.L. Bean Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter should be your next purchase for your boudoir. Available in four sizes and two warmths, this comforter boasts a 100% cotton shell and a premium white goose down filler that is responsibly sourced and has been washed and rinsed enough times to make it hypoallergenic. The comforter is constructed by the company's Permabaffle gate system, which helps stop the filler from shifting throughout the comforter causing it to get lumpy. It has built-in loops that can be attached to a duvet cover and a one-year return policy.


Ideal for: Those who want the ultimate comforter for their bedtime sanctuary.








  • Price: $399-$589
  • Warmths: Warm and Warmer
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
  • Construction: Permabaffle
  • Shell Material: 100% cotton
  • Filler Material: White goose down
  • Duvet Loops: Yes
  • Machine Washable: Can be washed and dried in a large commercial machine
  • Certifications: None
  • Warranty/Sleep Trial: One-year return policy


Pros: 







  • White goose down is hypoallergenic and sustainably sourced
  • Permabaffle construction helps keep filler from moving throughout the comforter. 
  • Comes in four sizes


Cons: 







  • Expensive
  • Only available in cream


How to Take Care of Your Comforter

Now that you’ve selected the best comforter for your bed, here are some tips on how to ensure it lasts for a long time.







  • Make Sure to Read the Label — While this may seem like an obvious tip, most people never take the time to read the label that tells you how to properly take care of your comforter. So before you snip it off because it's annoying you, take the time to read it thoroughly so you understand how to clean and take care of it. If you do cut it off, stow it somewhere safe so you can access it when you need it.
  • Wash it Right — As you'll learn from that label we just talked about, following the laundering instructions for your comforter is essential to making sure it lasts a long time. If it says it's not machine washable, believe it — you'll be happier in the long run! 
  • Use a Duvet Cover — While some comforters that come in a variety of colors and patterns do not necessarily require a duvet cover, others that are a pristine white or lighter color can certainly benefit from the protection that a duvet cover can provide. 
  • Store it Properly — As not all comforters were designed to be used throughout the entire year, you may find you need to switch out and store comforters at some point. In general, make sure to store your comforter in a cool, dry, clean place like a linen closet. And you can also try placing it in a bag made from a breathable fabric — not plastic — for an extra layer of protection.


Do you have a comforter you love to snuggle up with? Tell us about it in the comments below!

Frequently asked questions

Have a question about this project?

Comments

Join the conversation

Next